Search This Blog

Thursday, September 23, 2010

Cinderella, the Color Pink and Kiddie Pagents

Jezebel, Peggy Orenstein and feminism, in general, I love you.  I really do!  I sympathize.  I appreciate how much you care.  But really, you're taking things a little too far.  For those of you who aren't aware (which would be anyone who doesn't spend their day on Feministing) Peggy Orenstein, prolific feminist writer and journalist, has a new book coming out - months from now.  And already, the debates are gearing up.  Orenstein's book is titled Cinderella Ate My Daughter: Dispatches From The Front Lines Of The New Girlie-Girl Culture.  She had lunch with some of the girls at Jezebel and they all sat down to talk about how Cinderella and the color pink ruin little girls.  Their biggest issue seemed to be that 6 year olds like wearing lip gloss, but basically, they think that society is forcing our girls into this "girlie" culture and limiting their options.  I didn't particularly agree with everything they were saying, but I wasn't insulted until I read this:

When discussing the volume of all things pink and glittery for little girls, Jezebel's article had this to say, "But someone has to be buying.  Orenstein noted that parents have to be driving the Toddlers and Tiaras-ification of children who are young enough to accept no as an answer."  Hold it right there ladies.  If you just compared me to those pagent-pushing selfish famewhores, we have a problem.  A very large problem. See there's this little thing called reality.  And in reality, people don't just write books about their daughters or post blog articles about their toys.  In reality, people actually raise daughters.  In this cool little place called the real world, there is a difference between Toddlers and Tiaras and letting my daughter play dress up.  I also believe there is a difference between Bratz dolls, which have been overtly sexualized, and a Barbie princess in a poufy, pink dress. 

Young children are very rarely "all or nothing".  Most kids find a balance in the types of toys they play with.  My daughter has the girliest bedroom you can imagine.  Pink walls, a huge castle, lots of princesses.  She even has a canopy bed where she can tuck in her princess babies.  She also has 4 different types of blocks, every plastic animal you can imagine, an art desk and a large collection of dinosaurs.  My very feminine daughter who wears a tutu almost daily to dance around our house has a new favorite TV show.  It's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.  In her dress up trunk, next to the blue Disney Cinderella dress and matching light up slippers, are swords, axes and armor. I'm hoping that I've given enough examples to show that children can like a variety of different toys and types of play.  The simple existence of "girlie-girl" play does not mean that every girl grows up thinking that its all she can ever do. 

Jezebel may think its a tragedy, but yes, my daughter likes wearing lip gloss.  Why?  Because her mother wears it!  How many times as children were we all just trying to emulate our parents?  If my daughter is going to emulate me in her play, I want her to know that I can be a little girlie and still be a strong woman.  I hope that she'll learn that wearing lip gloss doesn't make her stupid, just like ignoring it won't make her smart.  Life is not a Legally Blonde movie and changing her clothes won't make her more intelligent or prepared for life's challenges.  But if those clothes can give her confidence, there is nothing wrong with feeling pretty. 

At the end of the article, Jezebel admits that denying all gender-specific toys normally makes kids want them more.  Instead of trying to change what kids want, maybe the best approach is to talk to your kids about their toys.  And why they want them.  Maybe we can let the girls have Barbies and introduce them to other activities.  My house transitions from ballet class to soccer games pretty easily.  That's the reality.  Cinderella never ruined anyone, pink is just a color, and wearing lipstick doesn't enter our daughters in the Little Miss Angel Beauty Pagent.

No comments:

Post a Comment