Search This Blog

Monday, November 8, 2010

Private v. Public

At around 3 years old, our toddlers present us with a very serious, mind-boggling, insecurity-riddled debate.  Private versus Public schooling.  The proponents on both sides are vocal and passionate.  My husband and I are smack in the middle of this very touchy topic.  His mother taught at Catholic school, mine in a public school.  His school held Mass, mine had a Religious Ed trailer in the parking lot.  We should be passionately arguing the pros and cons of schools named for Saints vs. Presidents.  But we're not.  We both tend to believe that children can do well in both environments.  And that parental involvement in education is a lot more effective than a high tuition cost in preparing our daughter for the world.

Everyone you meet has a horror story about a certain school, public or private or charter.  Hopefully, every past student also has a teacher that reached out and touched them, one that they will forever champion and hold as the ideal.  In my high school, I had magnificent teachers who pushed me to think and work hard. I also had lazy and mean-spirited professors, most of whom I can no longer remember their names.  (It hasn't been that long, either.)  More than anything, schooling choices seem to be a matter of tradition, but which side will we follow?  Mine or my husband's?

Honestly, we're not sure yet.  Thankfully we have a couple more years before we have to decide.  In that discussion, my head will continue to circle back to an article written Charles Blow of the New York Times.  Blow discusses what he calls "the civility gap" of private schools.  He quotes a study conducted with school-age boys where private school students admitted to using more racial slurs and insults.  The private-schooled also admitted to more bullying, teasing and taunting. 

I'm not saying that this information is representative of all private-schooled children.  Obviously, I find my husband to be one of the most accepting and kind men I know.  But I do wonder if the idea of a "select few" group of students promotes intolerance among these young kids?  Also, do these children grow out of their intolerance as they grow and meet people outside of their schools? 

When it comes to schooling, there can't be a right or wrong answer.  Mostly because our children all have different needs and methods of learning.  That doesn't stop parents from wanting to give their children the best opportunity possible.  I only hope that I have the ability to see what the best choice for my daughter will be.  I also hope that whatever her school lacks, be it tolerance or discipline or diversity, my husband and I will be there to step in and teach our daughter in the best ways we know how.

No comments:

Post a Comment