We know, she married the obnoxiously loud, short and crazy man. We all wish that he would go away. We all wish that we could just remember her from her adorable Dawson's days. We liked her back then. Now she's that friend who married a maniac and you stopped returning her calls.
So whenever Katie Holmes says something, anything really, but especially about parenting, we all like to tear her down a peg. First, let's be honest, her daughter is flippin adorable. And no matter how annoying her husband is, let's all remember Gwenyth's Grammy performance and agree that Katie is not the most ridiculously clueless celebrity mom out there.
Normally, I wouldn't bother standing up for a woman that most people are determined to dislike. But today, it's not just that I don't hate Katie Holmes, I also agree with her. Katie recently said that she's thinking about a second child because her daughter, Suri, wants a sibling. And that adorable and stylish little tyke is apparently "hard to say no to".
Obviously (according to someone other than me), this is a horrible reason to have another child. I mean really, you're child is so spoiled that you're going to create another just to keep it happy? Insane! Except, my grandmother always told me that every boy should have a brother and every girl should have a sister. She really wanted another child so that my uncle could have a brother. She wanted this because she spent her whole childhood wanting a sister. Personally, even when we don't agree, I feel extremely lucky to have a sister close to my age, because I relate to her in a way that I can't with anyone else on earth.
I'm not saying that everyone should have a sibling. I've never been sure about that. But I can understand the desire to give your child a sibling. And I think that most people can. For a couple years now, my daycare provider has been telling me that my daughter needed a sibling. She seems to think that my daughter is spoiled... She said that my daughter needed to experience what it was like when someone else demanded her parents' attention.
Whatever your specific reason, I think there are plenty of people who wanted their children to have siblings. We all know that we have to be prepared and capable of taking care of another child. Can we afford it? Do we have the emotional strength and stability? Do we have support? These are important questions to ask. But if all those answers are yes, and our child wants a sibling and we want to give them one, that's not a bad thing. My daughter doesn't even want a sibling, and I'm trying to force one on her!
Let me be honest, I just want to be pregnant. So I'm pretty determined to support anyone else who wants to be pregnant too. Am I being crazy? Is this an awful reason to want another child? Or is it a valid part of the second child discussion?

I think it's disgusting that your daycare provider is telling you to "give your child a sibling." How does she know whether it's by choice or not? How unprofessional, I would report her if I were you for overstepping boundaries.
ReplyDeleteThe only valid reason for having another is that you want another child. If you are having one "Just" to "give" a sibling to your older kid, that seems just a little harsh (especially for the 2nd kid).
ReplyDeleteI would also change day care providers!! How rude!!!
It's easy to say that my daycare provider overstepped on that one. And sometimes, she and I don't agree. But no matter what, I trust her with my daughter. I trust that she loves my daughter with all her heart. I trust that she will work her butt off to do what's best for my daughter. In the end, I can handle a couple of disagreements, in exchange for always feeling confident about the place where my daughter spends her days.
ReplyDeleteAnd I agree, Conflicted Mama, if the "giving your child a sibling" is your only reason, it's not enough. You have to want a child yourself and be able to provide for it. I just don't think that the sibling argument is an invalid one. I think it can be part of the decision.