I don't watch Teen Mom or 16 and Pregnant. I refuse to buy magazines that use these young women as cover models. In general, I try not to discuss them that often. But everyone in America knows about Amber Portwood, the teenage mother from Anderson, Indiana with anger issues, cleanliness issues and a big ol' tattoo. As we've discussed on The Gloss, people in Indiana are embarrassed for our state. Personally, I'm a little embarrassed for young motherhood in general.
I wasn't a teenager when I had my daughter. I was a 21 year old woman with an amazing support system. Those five years make a huge difference in maturity, from high school student to college student. From someone who lives with their parents, to someone who knows how to pay their own bills and manage their money. My relationship with the father of my daughter may not have worked out, but it was never hostile or violent. And of course, I got to go through my parenting struggles in private, or maybe with the help of my mother and sister, instead of parading my deficiencies in front of millions of viewers. In a thousand and one ways, my situation was different from Amber Portwood's. It was easier than these teen moms, who so many people watch and talk about. And it was still difficult. It was still filled with stress and doubt and mistakes.
Maybe that's why I have a hard time with all of Amber Portwood's negative press. Do I think she should be punished for committing assault in front of her daughter? Of course I do. Do I think that someone who beats on another person in front of their child should have custody of said child? Not at all. I believe that before this young woman can raise her daughter, she needs time to grow up herself. She needs to control her depression and anger. She needs to mature. She needs to put the needs of her child before her own wants.
But she also needs sympathy. She needs support. She needs an education. And hopefully, her daughter can become an inspiration for more than just body art. Hopefully, when she looks at that beautiful little girl, she can find an ambition within herself to be better. The only way she's going to do that is to break every tie she has with MTV, with Star magazine and with media attention of any kind. This young woman faces jail time. I hope she uses it to disappear from the public eye. I hope she comes out determined to be a better mother. And I hope that I never see another picture of her, mugshot or otherwise, on the cover of weekly tabloid.
But even if I hear every detail of her trial and then her recovery, even if she gets her own destructive spin-off to display her rehab efforts, I won't be commenting. I won't be analyzing or condemning or offering any more advice. Because what Amber Portwood's daughter needs more than anything is the world to forget about her and her mother. She needs a stable, loving family, whether they're naturally hers or not. And there's no way she'll achieve that while custody battles are being fought in front of millions of viewers.
See, while Amber's story is sad, her daughter's story is heartwrenching. This little girl was born into a difficult situation, made worse through amplification. As she grows older, she'll learn about the TV show. She'll see the tapes of her mother beating her father. She'll read the stories about her mother out drunk and partying. She'll know how her mother lost custody of her. And worst of all, she'll know that everyone else knows these things too. So I hope that no more chapters to this little girl's life are made public knowledge. I hope that as she grows up, she gets to learn what privacy feels like. Because this little girl deserves that. She deserves time to become her own person, and then decide if she wants to share herself with the world. I hope she gets to make that choice for herself.
So, Amber Portwood, here is my appeal to you, from one young mother to another: Think about your daughter first. Use this time to ween yourself off of attention and media coverage. Use every tool available to you to become a better mother to your daughter. And then never, ever, ever tell any of us about it.
