A teacher in New York has been removed from the classroom for revealing that her former career involved having sex for money. It’s not that a student’s father was her former John or something, the school found out because Melissa Petro wrote about her past experiences in Huffington Post and The Rumpus. She didn’t hide her identity or shy away from revealing where she worked. She wrote about her life as a sex worker, knowing and hoping, that someday she would get to have this fight, a fight about whether a former prostitute should be able to work with young children.
We all have a past. Each and every one of us have made mistakes and done things that we don’t want elementary school kids to emulate. But there are certain mistakes that prohibit people from working with children. One of those mistakes is committing a crime. In most school districts across the country, any felony or misdemeanor disqualifies you from the teaching profession. The thought goes, those who commit crimes should not be in a position to influence impressionable kids. Thinking back to my elementary art teachers, the only impression they gave off was “kooky”. But that’s not so much a crime as it is adorable and endearing. In the state of New York, as well as 48 others, prostitution is a crime. We can debate the justness of that crime for the next year, but right now, it’s still a crime. And Melissa Petro participated in this “lifestyle” as she called it, knowing that it was a crime. For me, it shouldn’t be a big surprise that she’s getting in trouble with her employer.
Some of Melissa Petro’s supporters compare her situation to gay and lesbian teachers being kicked out of the classroom. To me, this is a completely incongruous comparison. Homosexuality is not a choice; it’s the way a person is born. It’s also a protected class under Federal Law, if we’d like to get technical about things. “Former Call Girl” is not exactly the same thing, although if Spitzer ever gets re-elected, that might change. As Petro describes her career, it was a choice. Sex work is not only something she did, it’s something she’s been researching and writing about for quite some time. And she states pretty clearly that she wants this fight. She wants to challenge preconceived notions about sex work. So getting disciplined by her employer… she was ready for this to happen. And she admitted to enjoying publicity.
If Melissa Petro wanted to make a stir, here you go darlin! But comparing a woman who was actively seeking to make her private life a part of her professional life to the countless gay and lesbian teachers who simply wanted to do their job and leave their private life at home is ridiculous. If we need a public debate about the career paths available to former sex workers, ok. Let’s have that. But I don’t find it helpful to compare this woman’s battle to that of homosexuals looking for workplace acceptance and equality.
