Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Salon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Salon. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Salon Doesn't Hate Mothers

I was a little harsh on Salon this week.  But they seemed pretty dismissive of motherhood in general, which made me critical.  I have to admit, I'm glad to see that they presented another side of the story from one of their Open Salon blogs.  Enjoy!

Monday, February 28, 2011

Maybe An Overreaction...

Over at Salon, Mary Elizabeth Williams is taking Natalie Portman to task for calling her pregnancy "the most important role of my life".  Williams, whose work I thoroughly enjoy on a reglar basis, doesn't understand why Portman has to downplay the biggest achievement of her career (winning an Oscar) by comparing it to carrying a baby. 

I've never won an Oscar, so I'm pretty sure that I can't relate to trying to accept the award without looking and sounding like a complete idiot.  I imagine that this is more difficult than one would think.  And maybe I just love Natalie Portman in all her awkward adorableness, but I think she deserves some slack here. 

Yes, lots of wonderful women have done amazing things in their career, even if they have children.  Yes, lots of women without children have done amazing things.  And no, a woman's sole purpose on this earth isn't to raise cute mini-me's or spawn the future generation.  Most women in the 21st century get that.  We're thankful that we have opportuities to be both great mothers and successful professionals. 

But there is something about pregnancy that makes a woman feel special and incredibly proud of her ability to produce children.  Be as pessimistic about pregnancy as you like, talk about the nausea, the swollen ankles and the crippling heartburn, we all discuss those things frequently.  No matter how rotten your body may feel, the realization that it's growing another person is amazing.  Feeling the heartbeat and the kicks and the movement, it's an incredible experience.  It's not the only incredible experience in a woman's life.  But it's a key one. 

So if Natalie Portman is so high on pregnancy that she wants to refer to it as her most important performance, let her.  Smile and nod and wish her the very best.  For some women, they decide that being a mother really is the most important thing they will ever do.  They have every right to feel that way.  And you know what, I commmend them for making that commitment.  Some women choose to be mothers and also have a career.  I'm happy for them too.  Just because Natalie Portman has already made amazing professional accomplishments doesn't mean that she can't decide to be a mother and nothing else.  Whatever she decides, we should all be happy for her. 

And if it turns out that this was just one of those light-headed pregnancy moments brought on by the joy of WINNING AN OSCAR, let's support her when she goes back to work, too.  Basically, there are a lot of feminist issues to tackle out there.  I don't think a euphoric acceptance speech is one of them.

Congratulations Ms. Portman!  I wish you and your little one the very best.