The New York Times thinks that my generation of mothers just really wants to get along. And actually, I would love that. But first of all, most women rarely agree with me. Secondly, even if we do want to be respectful (and I'm sincerely hoping that we do), that doesn't mean that we avoid all the difficult or debatable topics.
Some media writer decided to compare The View with its newer update The Talk. Barbara and Company are the hard-hitting combative bunch, ready to rip off their earrings and smear on the Vaseline. Julie Chen and her BFFs are basically on an extended playdate after their Mommy and Me Yoga Class.
I love the New York Times, but this is honestly such a non-trend, derived from two crappy daytime TV shoes. Young moms agree on everything? Have you been to a mothering website lately? Check out a couple of the comments of my posts at TheGloss, sweetie. Not everyone agrees!
The View thrives off drama and debate. The Talk wants to be like a mommy support group, (seriously, that was the premise). These aren't generational indicators, they're marketing strategies and production techniques. Today's generation of mothers are just as varied and opinionated as our mother's and grandmother's generations. We don't all agree and don't always get along. Of course there are generational differences in motherhood, but lack of debate is not one of them. I resent being compared to a fluffy, fake-sorority sisterhood who refuses to address actual issues and settles for lots of squealing and clapping. And I'm positive that my mother would be insulted by the thought that she's a shrill wench who can't have a serious intellectual debate without foaming at the mouth, crying or storming off.
Search This Blog
Showing posts with label The Talk. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Talk. Show all posts
Tuesday, November 30, 2010
"The Talk" Doesn't Symbolize Anything But Bad TV
Labels:
motherhood,
The Talk,
The View,
Women's Media
Thursday, October 21, 2010
I Hate "The View", but I Loathe "The Talk"
Just in case anyone doubts my dedication to mommy-blogging, I would like to submit this into evidence: I watched two full episodes of "The Talk". (I may have used the 30-second skip ahead numerous times, but that's just good use of DVR.) In case you're lucky enough not to have heard of this generic-titled new show, "The Talk" is supposed to be "The View" for mothers. Creator Sarah Gilbert said she was trying to fashion a show after a great experience in a motherhood support group. The most ridiculous part of her explanation was that she said the group wasn't just female friends, they talked about important issues effecting mothers and women, in general. If the first two days are any indication, these women are not planning on discussing any topic heavier Facebook. And not even the dark, misogynistic Social Network type of Facebook. I mean the, "I friended my kids so I could see who they were hanging out with" Facebook.
The entire show was a lesson in awkwardness. From the overly nice family stories of Leah Remini's hospitality and her daughter's homemade presents for Sharon Osbourne to the monogrammed Tupperware presented to each hostess, these women displayed the worst stereotypical mothers imaginable. Even their "serious issue" segment about when to talk to children about sex included lots of squeaking, shrill, "Oh my God, I have to say the word VAGINA?" At least when Whoopi and Joy act like spoiled brats who can't make coherent arguments, they're talking about a serious topic. These women screamed, plugged their ears and repeatedly said, "Ew! Ew! Ewwwwwww!" in response to Holly Robinson Peete's remark that she believes in using the proper terms for body parts. Yes, that means telling your child that they have a vagina or a penis. Which, by the way, is what almost every child therapist would recommend.
I have to admit, I planned on watching the show for an entire week before I gave my overall assessment. But I just don't think I can sit through another tortured, timed and overly sugared minute. The concept of the show wasn't horrible. Sarah Gilbert, who actually seems to be intelligent, wanted to create a show with a variety of mothers to discuss important topics. And with the visceral responses most mothers have about parenting issues, there was the possibility for some serious debate about the way we parent in America. Unfortunately, CBS seems to think that all mothers care about is Taylor Swift songs and getting your pan back at the end of a potluck.
The women of "The View" are all mothers, even if that isn't the basis of their show. And yet, their used uteruses haven't prevented them from discussing (at least attempting to discuss), actual newsworthy events. They may get shrill and obnoxious, but they bring on guests and try to speak with them. The first two guests of "The Talk", Christie Brinkley and Jennifer Lopez, were barely interviewed. They all spent a lot of time saying how gorgeous they were, how adorable their kids are. They asked one serious question a piece, at least JLo's was about a current controversy, her children fronting the Gucci children's campaign. But really, the entire show was a good idea gone terribly wrong.
Women everywhere have different parenting views. We each make decisions about what works best for ourselves and our children. Exploring those differences, and even why we are all so defensive of our choices, would be interesting and informative. But that will never happen on a show where the mention of talking to your children about sex creates middle school screeching. "The View" may not be able to interview Bill O'Reilly, but "The Talk" wouldn't know a Hot Topic if it tap-danced in the middle of their pretty new set.
The entire show was a lesson in awkwardness. From the overly nice family stories of Leah Remini's hospitality and her daughter's homemade presents for Sharon Osbourne to the monogrammed Tupperware presented to each hostess, these women displayed the worst stereotypical mothers imaginable. Even their "serious issue" segment about when to talk to children about sex included lots of squeaking, shrill, "Oh my God, I have to say the word VAGINA?" At least when Whoopi and Joy act like spoiled brats who can't make coherent arguments, they're talking about a serious topic. These women screamed, plugged their ears and repeatedly said, "Ew! Ew! Ewwwwwww!" in response to Holly Robinson Peete's remark that she believes in using the proper terms for body parts. Yes, that means telling your child that they have a vagina or a penis. Which, by the way, is what almost every child therapist would recommend.
I have to admit, I planned on watching the show for an entire week before I gave my overall assessment. But I just don't think I can sit through another tortured, timed and overly sugared minute. The concept of the show wasn't horrible. Sarah Gilbert, who actually seems to be intelligent, wanted to create a show with a variety of mothers to discuss important topics. And with the visceral responses most mothers have about parenting issues, there was the possibility for some serious debate about the way we parent in America. Unfortunately, CBS seems to think that all mothers care about is Taylor Swift songs and getting your pan back at the end of a potluck.
The women of "The View" are all mothers, even if that isn't the basis of their show. And yet, their used uteruses haven't prevented them from discussing (at least attempting to discuss), actual newsworthy events. They may get shrill and obnoxious, but they bring on guests and try to speak with them. The first two guests of "The Talk", Christie Brinkley and Jennifer Lopez, were barely interviewed. They all spent a lot of time saying how gorgeous they were, how adorable their kids are. They asked one serious question a piece, at least JLo's was about a current controversy, her children fronting the Gucci children's campaign. But really, the entire show was a good idea gone terribly wrong.
Women everywhere have different parenting views. We each make decisions about what works best for ourselves and our children. Exploring those differences, and even why we are all so defensive of our choices, would be interesting and informative. But that will never happen on a show where the mention of talking to your children about sex creates middle school screeching. "The View" may not be able to interview Bill O'Reilly, but "The Talk" wouldn't know a Hot Topic if it tap-danced in the middle of their pretty new set.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

