Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Wall Street Journal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wall Street Journal. Show all posts

Thursday, December 23, 2010

Christmas Cluelessness

Every year on Tax Day, the Wall Street Journal runs a story about a small businessman who worked hard, made millions and is really pissed that he has to share some of it.  These men, and they are always men, started out as lower or middle class, but through nothing other than hard work and determination (It never helped that they were white men with decent educations.  In fact, that makes it harder.  Affirmative action, ya know.)  these pillars of virtue made a fortune.  Really, they would love to be more involved with charities and philanthropic causes, but they have to pay so much in taxes, they just can't spare anymore.  For the past couple years, I thought that the Wall Street Journal would be smart enough to cease and desist.  They must realize that people out there are losing jobs, homes and healthcare.  These 'poor me' stories relate to almost no one and piss most intelligent people off.  But they keep going, year after year.

Today, I think the New York Times has caught the Journal's tone deafness.  Apparently, that crap is contagious.  In a holiday season where plenty of families are struggling to buy their children presents at all, the Times runs a profile entitled "A Poor Little Rich Girl at Christmas".  It's a profile of Ivana Lowell, the daughter of a Guinness brewery heiress.  Now, I'm not saying the woman isn't interesting.  And her mother definitely sounds a little crazy, so I'm sure her life wasn't always princess shoes and ponies. But really?  That title.  That Goddamn title.  That was necessary, Times editor? 

Lowell has definitely led an interesting life.  Her autobiography has been highly praised and I'm sure it's a great read.  I also realize that not all rich people are terrible human beings.  Their lives are just as capable of falling apart as anyone else's.  And honestly, Lowell's holidays sound a little rough as well. 

But please, look at the country around you!  Millions of people are losing their homes.  In my city alone, the families that applied to receive Christmas presents from a local charity more than doubled.  These are families that won't be able to provide their children Christmas presents, so the charity asks wealthy individuals or companies to come together and sponsor a family, buying toys and goods for the family.  This year, thousands of families got turned away because there weren't enough sponsors.  That's in one city, in one of the smallest states in the country.  There are millions of families out there who need help.  Millions of kids who won't get the toys they hoped for, because their parents can't afford them.  There are millions of families who won't be eating duck on Christmas, they'll be visiting local churches and shelters. 

So, Ivana Lowell, I'm sorry that you had to shill your book at such an inopportune time.  But, a poor little rich girl just doesn't illicit the sympathy that it once did.  And Times editors, every once in a while, it pays to look beyond the countries 5 major cities.  Or even, look within your cities at the people you try to forget about.  Run a story on what Christmas is like for normal people struggling through a particularly heart-wrenching economic meltdown.  Honestly, no one wants you to be anything like the Journal ever again.