Search This Blog

Showing posts with label tragedy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tragedy. Show all posts

Sunday, February 13, 2011

Tragedy Just Isn't The Time For Judgemental Mothers

Two realities that we should all be aware of:

One, tragedies are terribly sad and often have no explanation.

Two, once you have a child, you suddenly feel like you have the right to pass judgement upon absolutely everyone in the world.

So here's the tragedy and here's the judgement.

In case you aren't in the mood to click links, a 19 year old mother struck her son in the head because she thought he was "possessed" and is now being charged with his murder.  I think we can all agree, this is heart-wrenchingly sad.  But even though no one has determined the mental capacity or possible mental illness of this woman, a blogger at The Stir believes that she's capable of denouncing this whole "psychotic break" business.

Listen, I know that lots of people want to make sense out of tragedies.  And sometimes, the easiest way to do that is to say, "That bitch is evil!"  But honestly, comparing a woman who killed her son to your children "pushing your buttons" is not just ridiculously shallow, it's ignorant.  Ignorant and disgusting and unbelievably callous.  Yes, random woman sitting on your couch, just like I am, we've all said that we could "kill" our children if they didn't settle down.  No, we didn't do it.  And no, that doesn't mean we understand the type of mental disorder that would cause a mother to kill her child.  We can't begin to understand it.  And unless you have a couple of Ph.D's that you haven't mentioned and you've spent hours speaking to this woman, you don't get to have an opinion.  I don't care if you, too, have pushed a baby out.  That doesn't mean you understand the thought process of every other woman who's pushed a baby out.  Or else you would know how much I hate you right now.

So let's all say, this is terribly sad.  The whole thing is sad and heartbreaking and awful.  And then, let's leave it at that.