Well, I've already admitted that I don't read parenting books. So I'm not going to pretend that I would have ever picked up Gever Tulley's new thriller "Fifty Dangerous Things (You Should Let Your Children Do)". I'm not even really here to address the topic of his book. From the summary, it sounds like he thinks that parents protect their children too much and a little dangerous exploration helps kids grow. Since I'm not reading his argument, I'm going to reserve judgement on that.
My issue with Mr. Tulley's book is that he doesn't actually have any children. Mr. Tulley is a pedagogical theorist. Basically, he creates theories about how children learn. While I firmly believe that having a child doesn't make you an expert, can you be an expert without ever being responsible for a child's learning and well-being? There are extremely successful and hardworking teachers everywhere with no children. And I'm sure those teachers are just as capable in their job as teachers with their own offspring. But Tulley isn't just giving a couple pointers here, he's arguing for an entirely different way of parenting.
Can someone without a child understand the pressure that comes when your child's life is in your hands? Can a man who has never experienced the paranoia of motherhood tell me not to worry when my child runs with scissors? All in all, the thought of a man without any children telling me to, in effect, relax and let natural selection take its course is a little disturbing. It's definitely condescending.
I'm sure Mr. Tulley's intentions are good. And there are plenty of real parents who would argue for his methods. I remember some random mother who sent her 8 year old on a New York subway. The entire "free range parenting" movement is probably advance-ordering this book as I type. But those parents, they go home and look at a young son or daughter who depends on them for almost everything. The weight of that responsibility makes them different in my mind, from a theoretical academic who never has to meet the child who gets hurt playing with his "Fifty Dangerous Things".

No comments:
Post a Comment