Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Parenting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Parenting. Show all posts

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Children in Politics, Part II.

We're not in Wisconsin, but there's been a lot of protests here too.  Indiana is another of the Midwest states that's protesting Right to Work legistlation, as well as educational reform that would diminish teacher's union bargaining power.  I've been getting daily email updates about protests, rallies and support events.  I've considered attending some, though I'm not quite sure yet.

One thing I do know; I won't be taking my daughter. 

Months ago, I wrote about Tea Party coloring books and how much I disagree with them.  I defiantly stated that "the best time to discuss those politics with your child is when they're old enough to form their own opinions, not indoctrinate them directly after potty-training".  I have to admit, it was pretty easy to disagree with the Tea Party training loyal conservatives before they could even spell the word.  I generally disagree with the Tea Party, this was just one more way. 

Then a story popped up in the New York Times about a 3-year old at the Indiana State House, protesting with his father.  The little man with the "Don't Tread On Me" placard was pretty popular with the union supporters.  Honestly, I bet the child was completely adorable.  But, even though it's harder to disagree this time than it was the last, I'm still not sure that political rallies are an appropriate place for children.  Whether it's a philosophy I agree with or one I don't, union rights doesn't seem like the type of political issue that a child needs to have strong opinions about.

We all teach our children morals.  As parents, it's our job to instill values and life lessons.  I'm sure that there are plenty of people who would argue that teaching their children about their political beliefs was just another way of discussing morals and values.  When it comes to the culture wars, I'm sure that plenty of parents feel that way.  And honestly, there are some issues which I understand.  Personally, I will teach my daughter that all people have the right to love whoever they want.  I probably won't bring up marriage and the rights it grants (or doesn't grant), but I will teach her that all people should be treated equally and with respect.  I guess, some people might see this as a political belief. 

But the honest fact is that most political beliefs pit one side against another.  They create two separate teams, one that's right and one that's wrong.  Especially for children, who see almost everything as black and white, good vs. evil, with no middle ground at all, setting up political beliefs at an early age teaches you that the other party are the bad guys.  When the truth of the matter, the one that we all know deep down, is that most people want what's best for their country.  We just don't all agree on what "best" is.  Even if we agree on the desired outcome, odds are we won't agree on how to get there. 

This type of situation, one where both sides are filled with good people who are working their hardest to make their country a better place, yet they still disagree... that's a hard thing to communicate to young children.  Actually, it's pretty much impossible. 

Someday, I hope my daughter will feel motivated to get involved in her community.  I hope she'll understand the importance of volunteering her time to causes she believes in, whether they're politcal, social or spiritual.  But I don't want the foundation for that involvement to be a belief I indoctrinated before she could ride a bicycle.  I want it to be something that she believes deep down, in a thoughtful and serious way.  I want her to think about all those values and morals that I tried to teach her and apply them in the best way she sees fit.  If it turns out that she has different political beliefs than I do, I hope we can discuss them intelligently and respectfully.  I want these things for myself and my daughter.  But I won't get there by introducing my daughter to politics before she's ready to understand its complexities.

Having children at political rallies makes for great theatre.  It creates adorable and profound photo ops.  It makes for good news.  But it's not what I want for my daughter, whether I agree with the cause or not.

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

Parents, You Might Not Matter

At least to your child's eating habits.  While hyper-Mamas everywhere are terrified by a group of studies that show weak correlations between a parent's eating habits and their child's, I'm pretty flippin excited.  Why?  It's one less thing that I can mess up! 

Honestly, please think about this.  Everyday, scientists tell me that I could be doing one more thing to potentially ruin my daughter's life.  That french fry obsession while I was pregnant (and maybe after...) will lead to heart problems later, for me and my daughter.  Every time I turn on the TV, I might be hurting my daughter's IQ.  When we had to supplement with formula because I didn't produce enough milk, I could have caused a lifetime of allergy agony on my unsuspecting little girl.  Seriously, with every parenting decision I make, I'm pretty sure that someone out there could tell me how that ruins my daughter for all eternity. 

So anyone who wants to tell me, "Nope!  This might be something that kids decide for themselves," you are officially my new favorite person!  I realize the importance of teaching our children to eat healthy.  I know that no matter what the study says, I need to give my daughter nutritious food and teach her to appreciate what food does for our bodies.  But knowing that even if I screw up a little, she might still be ok... that's a blessing. 

So thank you, Dr. Youfa Wang, you just made me breath one tiny sigh of relief.  Now, I'm going to go home and worry about what is influencing my daughter, if I'm not.

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

10 Toys That Are Just Toys

I know that mothers can be neurotic and paranoid.  We're pretty sure that every little thing we do will have a lasting (and normally negative) impact on the rest of our child's life.  And hey, that fear is a whole lot of pressure!  Personally, I worry that a scantily clad waitress will negatively effect my daughter's body image.  Do I have any proof?  Not really.  It's pretty difficult to proof a single thing's impact when there are a million different factors that go into child-rearing.

All that being said, I'm pretty positive that this psychologist is full of shit and trying to scare mothers into never buying their child another toy... ever.  Because apparently, half the basic crap we grew up playing with will lead to huge psychological consquences for our young children.  Here is Dr. Jared DeFife's "10 Holiday Gifts that will Cause Your Child Lasting Psychological Damage".  As a helpful sidenote, I've added why this doctor needs to calm the fuck down. 

1. Elf on the Shelf.   The "Elf on the Shelf" is a Christmas tradition, where parents hide a small elf doll at various places around the house in the days leading up to Christmas.  The elf on the shelf is a "scout elf".  He watches over the children to make sure they are behaving and each night he flies to the North Pole to report back to Santa.  The feeling of constantly being watched by a magical creature that is just waiting for you to screw up is surely a breeding ground for a lifetime of paranoid psychopathology.
The whole idea of Santa bringing presents is predicated on the "Naughty and Nice" lists.  You have to behave if you want to get presents.  That sounds like positive reinforcement to me.  

 2. The Game of Life. Ah yes, there's nothing better than a board game reminding you that you could easily be condemned to a lifetime of underpaid salaries, house fires, bankruptcy and childlessness.
Obviously, the Game of Life is sending out a terrible message here.  You should probably play Clue instead, and figure out which one of your friends is a murderer.  Or Battleship, because it's never too soon to start studying war strategy.

3. Fisher Price Medical Kit. Hypochondriacs rejoice! Now every cough, sniffle, or boo-boo can be treated as a major medical emergency.
God, who would ever want to encourage their children to find medicine interesting.  It's not like you can make a career out of it.  Let the little one know that it's ok as a "hobby", but not something to be taken seriously. 

4. A Santa outfit. Dressing your child up in a Santa outfit for holiday photos is why your child will grow into an adolescent who hates you.
Ok, this might make your adolescent hate you.  But all adolescents hate you.  Trying to stop that is like trying to stop people from talking about Sarah Palin.  Give it up already.

5. A Barbie doll or superhero action figure. Can you say body image issues?
Superheros can definitely create unrealistic expectations.  Your child could start trying to fly or dangle on spider webs.  Or think that they could have rock hard, plastic abs. 
I'm not going to get into Barbie issues.  They've been beaten to death.  Yes, they can create body image issues too.  Yet we have the whole Disney princess collection at home.  Call me a hypocrite if you'd like.

6. The Magic 8-Ball.  See Schizotypal Personality Disorder criteria #2: odd beliefs or magical thinking that influences behavior (e.g., belief in clairvoyance, telepathy, or "sixth sense"...)
I'm sure that asking a magic-8 ball if Jason Curtis would take me to the freshman semi-formal is the reason that I wasted my money on that stupid Call Cleo scam.  I was just hooked from an early age.  Do you think there's a lawsuit somewhere in there? 

7. Curious George. He's an impulsive monkey with a pathological lack of attachment anxiety. Do you really want your child emulating this behavior? Hopefully your insurance plan covers stimulant medication.
Curious?  You mean suicidal!  Do you know what happens to monkeys who stray from their Mamas?  They die!  Please, lets all teach that lesson to our children.  Then we can whine about them refusing to move out 40 years from now.

8. The Espressione Café Retro. Why is an espresso machine sold through the Toys R Us website? If your child is already hooked on caffeine, a substance abuse problem is definitely in the future.
Your child is just one Mountain Dew away from a heroin addiction.  Think on that.

9. Tickle Me Elmo. Tickling a giggling furry creature is a sure-fire way to kick-start sexual fetishism.
You don't even want to know what the little freaks will do with Snuffaluffagus.

10. Etch-a-sketch. Your child will spend hours working on a deeply meaningful artistic creation, only to have it wiped away at the slightest jostling. A psychologically devastating reminder of the ubiquity of loss and the ephemeral nature of existence. Also, no building sand castles on the beach.
You had the next Degas on your hands.  Then you shook his masterpiece away so you could try to write your name in connecting lines.  Now he's going to waste his life in a low-level job and hate you until the day he dies.

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Stilettos for PreTeens... They Might Be Illegal

In the UK, at least.  David Cameron and British government are considering legislation and restrictions on companies that sell hypersexualized merchandise to children.  They are also focusing on the advertising directed at kids which could influence them to purchase inappropriately sexy clothing, (Sorry Miley!  Don't visit that side of the pond!)  What products is the government targeting?  Padded bras for pre-tweens, anything with suggestive phrases, high heels and hot pants. 

As a lover of shoes, can I really support any government banning them?  Yes, I can.  I agree that children's clothing, especially for the pre-teen set, has gotten exceedingly trashy.  Honestly, I've walked through the mall and thought, "Brenna is going to hate me!  I'm never going to let her wear any of that!"  Other times, I think myself and my younger clothing choices.  They were never very pretty, but were they raunchy?  Was I trying to be sexy or just trying to fit in?  So in lots of ways, the banning of sexualized clothing for youngsters saves parents the trouble of having to debate and argue with their children about what's really appropriate.

But that debate can be a good thing.  I may not have always been the cutest, but my mother made me stop and think about the clothing I was wearing.  And what type of image it presented.  Sometimes, I still went with the sluttier option, but I did think about it first.  In the end, it is the parents who help their children learn about appropriate clothing and respecting your body.  No amount of government regulation can teach a young girl that padded bras and thongs are going to portray an image that girls simply aren't ready for.  Women need to be having these conversations with their daughters.  And they need to be able to say, "I'm sorry.  But you're too young."  Once a girl hits her teenage years, and might possibly be earning her own money, you still want her to be able to make appropriate and classy choices for herself.  (Ok, I know that I was definitely not classy.  But I'm hoping Brenna could be.) 

In the end, I think the British government is trying to address a serious problem.  Unfortunately, they aren't the ones who need to be taking that responsibility.  Parents and open communication are the only way teach young women how to dress appropriately for their age.

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

The Slutty Kid Costume Conundrum

Here in Indiana, our local children's zoo has Halloween weekends.  They make adorable animals entirely out of gourds.  They introduce kids to creepy animals and tell you why you shouldn't be afraid of snakes and spiders and bats. (Which is all a lie, you should be petrified!)  And they hand out lots of candy.  Walking through on a Saturday is an onslaught of adorableness.  All the little kids are dressed up and excited and posing for pictures with Broomhilda the Nice Witch.  Really, it deserves to be in Thornton Wilder play.

But as I walked through the Zoo's Halloween Celebration (they don't even call it haunted and it has no night time hours), I started to stare at the kids costumes around me.  And like most mothers I know, I got a little judgemental.  When a nine year old girl walked by in a "Princess Jasmine" type costume, complete with bra top, exposed belly and sheer pants, I leaned over to my husband and whispered, "Brenna is never wearing a costume that shows her stomach for Halloween."  I made a quick, proud glance down at my daughter's discreet puppy-dog costume.  My husband looked at me and said, "If our future son wants to be Jasmine, I'm vetoing you."  "Why?" "Because you will not oppress him, Lindsay!"  This is what happens when you try to have a conversation with my husband. 

Actually, he was trying to prove to me that I was being ridiculous.  And it might have worked.  Thinking back to that costume, I have to admit something...  Brenna has a Princess Jasmine costume in her dress up trunk right now.  And it shows her stomach.  Would I let her wear this costume in public?  Not right now and maybe not ever.  She hasn't asked yet, so I'm not sure. 

But a lot of the typical girls costumes that cause parental concern aren't slutty for the sake of being slutty.  Most of them are costumes that adults have perverted into a highly sexualized image.  Cheerleaders commonly wear revealing uniforms (Hello, Hellcats!) and therefore, so do the children who idolize them.  Princess Jasmine and Ariel both walk around in bras.  Likewise, their costumes normally show some belly. 

I agree that "Jailbait" costumes or costumes that are sexy for no reason have been on the rise.  And some of them are pretty disturbing.  But maybe moms, myself included, need to be a little more open-minded when we see a pirate costume with a short skirt.  Those skirts probably aren't any shorter than the dress clothes hanging in our kids' closets.  And to be honest, the young girls' costumes are nothing in comparison to what their mothers, aunts or older sisters are wearing these days.

Monday, October 11, 2010

You Don't Want Kids? I Don't Care!

You know, lots of childless people complain that they are tired of hearing why they should have children. They don’t like society’s constant urging to procreate and they really hate it when parents try to tell them how wonderful it is to have children. Whenever there’s an article about how having a child can complete your life, there are lots of angry, ‘My life is complete without needing anyone else!’ comments. My normal response is, “Good for you! I don’t actually care if you have children, because I know that not everyone’s experience and life are identical.” But I understand that some of these non-breeders feel a tad defensive. To be fair, some parents are intensely obnoxious when explaining how important their little bundle of joy is. Even I feel defensive around those people. I self-consciously start to think, “My daughter didn’t change every single detail of my life. I don’t have a whole new perspective. I can’t hear a butterfly flap its wings. Have I done something wrong?” So yea, I get it.

However, as of late, I’m tired of hearing about why you don’t want children. You’re career-oriented, you’re focused on you, it’s not the right time… I don’t care! Last week, a co-worker stopped by my desk to chat. This particular co-worker, a man five years older than me who continues to call me “Kiddo” no matter how many times I tell him how obnoxious that is, doesn’t stop by my desk often. The first question he asked me after the normal greetings was, “So are you and your husband going to start trying for more kids?” Odd. Just an odd question to start out with. I’ll give him the fact that I just got married this summer and I am actually trying to get pregnant, but still, it’s odd. “Umm… we’re talking about it.” I didn’t want to come out and say, “Oh yea, and I was at peak fertility last week so let’s keep our fingers crossed!”

So how did he follow up this extremely awkward ice breaker? It went a little like this, “I think I’m too selfish to have children. I’ve thought a lot about it. And you know, I wouldn’t be able to go out or drink whenever I want to. Think about all of the plans you have to cancel, just because you have a kid! I got angry when I had to leave my fishing trip because the park ranger wouldn’t let me have my dog unleashed. I got kicked out of the park just for my dog. What if I got kicked out for my kid? I would be pissed.” Now to explain, I live in Indiana. And to some men around here, a ruined fishing trip is a big deal. Geographical excuses aside, this was the first time I’d heard someone equate the inconveniences of a pet with the inconveniences of a child. And to be honest, I’m happy this man has decided not to have children. Because obviously, he shouldn’t be procreating. And God help the woman who tries to convince him otherwise. I really hope she fails in that attempt.

Now aside from this ridiculous story, why on earth was it told to me? A man, that I don’t even like, felt the need to come explain to me why he wasn’t going to have kids. Maybe he wanted me to say, “Oh no! You’ll be fine. I’m sure you’ll be a great dad.” But I’m not sure of that at all. Maybe he wanted to rub in my face that he’ll be free to drink whenever he wants and fish wherever he pleases. But I’m not jealous. Why does a person need to go out of their way to explain their parenting choices – or non-choices – to someone they barely have a relationship with.

I’ll address the “I’m too selfish” attitude later. But for now, I don’t want to hear about the joys of your empty uterus or unattached sperm. Believe it or not, I wasn’t always a mother. I remember what those times were like. And I’m happy that you’re making your own choices instead of following “society’s influence”. Don’t come to me with your justifications. I don’t want them and I certainly don’t need them. Why? Because I don’t care!



Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Should Those Without Children Dole Out Parenting Advice?

Well, I've already admitted that I don't read parenting books.  So I'm not going to pretend that I would have ever picked up Gever Tulley's new thriller "Fifty Dangerous Things (You Should Let Your Children Do)".  I'm not even really here to address the topic of his book.  From the summary, it sounds like he thinks that parents protect their children too much and a little dangerous exploration helps kids grow.  Since I'm not reading his argument, I'm going to reserve judgement on that. 

My issue with Mr. Tulley's book is that he doesn't actually have any children.  Mr. Tulley is a pedagogical theorist.  Basically, he creates theories about how children learn.  While I firmly believe that having a child doesn't make you an expert, can you be an expert without ever being responsible for a child's learning and well-being?  There are extremely successful and hardworking teachers everywhere with no children.  And I'm sure those teachers are just as capable in their job as teachers with their own offspring.  But Tulley isn't just giving a couple pointers here, he's arguing for an entirely different way of parenting. 

Can someone without a child understand the pressure that comes when your child's life is in your hands?  Can a man who has never experienced the paranoia of motherhood tell me not to worry when my child runs with scissors?  All in all, the thought of a man without any children telling me to, in effect, relax and let natural selection take its course is a little disturbing.  It's definitely condescending. 

I'm sure Mr. Tulley's intentions are good.  And there are plenty of real parents who would argue for his methods.  I remember some random mother who sent her 8 year old on a New York subway.  The entire "free range parenting" movement is probably advance-ordering this book as I type.  But those parents, they go home and look at a young son or daughter who depends on them for almost everything.  The weight of that responsibility makes them different in my mind, from a theoretical academic who never has to meet the child who gets hurt playing with his "Fifty Dangerous Things".

Monday, October 4, 2010

Parenting By the Book

I'm an avid reader.  However, there is one literary genre that I shy away from. To be honest, I avoid it like an infectious disease. It is the Pregnancy and Parenting section. I got through my entire pregnancy and Brenna’s infancy on a couple “What to Expect” books, the most common and straightforward guides you can get. Every once in a while, a friend or relative gives me some great book about children’s brain development or the importance of the arts and I pretend to read it, then return it.


I’m aware that these books are supposed to help. I’m sure the author’s intent is to make women as prepared and knowledgeable as they can be. And that sounds like a noble goal. It’s not that I don’t care about being a good parent; it’s that I don’t think all this extra knowledge really helps me. For a long time, this was my deep, dark secret. But today, I was passed a book that made me realize exactly why I needed to share my dislike.

The book is called “Origins: How Nine Months before Birth Shape the Rest of Our Lives”. Most people would read that title and think, “Oh my God, I have to know how I’m going to shape my child’s life!” And those inquisitive people will find out a hundred and one ways that mommy hurts baby by simply living a normal life. A quick glance through the book and a couple of online summaries tells me that the book is all about a new field of study called “fetal origins”. We’ve all known that drinking alcohol or smoking cigarettes while pregnant can hurt your child. I think we all agree those are bad things. Lately, those basic rules have given way to more restrictions: watch your mercury, sodium, aspartame (the sweetener for most “diet” products) and honey. Now, pregnant women can’t even gain all the weight they want without being criticized. Pregnant women are only supposed to gain 20-30 pounds, which to be honest takes all the fun out of being pregnant over the holidays. I loved having a viable excuse for stealing my niece’s Halloween candy or eating every piece of fudge my mother made in December. This was all bad enough.

“Origins” takes it even further. Now, mothers have to worry about causing diabetes, obesity, chronic depression and heart disease. We’re supposed to be careful about all of these things, but not stress out about it because that can cause pre-eclampsia. We should work out, so we don’t get too big. But we also shouldn’t pretend that we can do everything, we have precious cargo. And if all of this pressure to be the perfect pregnant incubator gets to be too much, you’d better not get depressed. Because that leads to low birth weight and depression in your child.

Is anyone else seeing the inconsistency here? We’re going to give you a ton of pressure and conflicting advice, but you can’t get stressed or upset about it. Pregnant women are already aware that we’re carrying a life inside of us. If we forget, it kicks us in the ribs as a reminder. For 10 whole months (and arguably a couple decades after), every decision we make must first consider someone else. Every minute of pregnancy is filled with the fear that we might screw up and hurt our baby. But pregnant women are still human! We can’t be expected to suddenly adopt a vegetarian diet, continue to jog 10 miles a week and never succumb to the enormous amount of hormones raging through our bodies.

I’m sure there are some enlightening lessons to be learned in “Origins” and most other pregnancy guides. I’m sure parenting books really can teach you ways to help your child learn and grow. But for me, the paranoia and stress that comes with them just isn’t worth it. I’m not a perfect mother and being reminded of that over and over again doesn’t help. Because, without any research to back me up, I’m pretty positive that being an involved, thoughtful and confident mother gives my daughter the best chance she can have. And if I get pregnant again, I think the little pulse ticking inside of me will be all the reminder I need that my decisions effect more than just myself.

So thank you to the wonderful little gems like “Origins”, “Life’s Little Treasures”, “The Happiest Baby on the Block” and “The Natural Pregnancy”. I’m sure you have the best of intentions. But I think a good long talk with my doctor and honest look at myself are the best ways to prepare for and deal with motherhood. If I need something to read, I’ll stick to alternating Chuck Palahniuk, Gabriel Garcia Marquez and Nora Roberts.

Monday, September 20, 2010

"Parent" Doesn't Mean "Old"

I ran into a high school acquaintance this weekend. Let's call him Colin, because that's his name. Colin was a senior when I was a freshman. I remember looking up to these seniors like they were the coolest beings on earth. Colin and his group of friends were the kind of guys I wanted to surround myself with, the kind of guys I wanted to want me. How that worked out, you'll all just have to guess. But my story today isn't about high school, it's about running into each other 6 years later.

Today, Colin is still cool. After graduating college, he worked hard, got a great job and a great apartment. He has a girlfriend, but they don't live together. He talks about working 60 hour weeks, has a Blackberry constantly buzzing at his hip and goes out to the bars almost every night. He's the epitome of late 20s cool; successful, busy social life, relatively unattached. We go through all this, with a little, "Wow, that sounds great," and "Good for you," on my part. Then comes the question, "So what are you doing now?" Well, I have a moderately fulfilling job, an amazing husband and a beautiful little girl. All of sudden, Colin has nothing else to say. He doesn't even know where to start. He's staring at me with wide eyes like I'm an endangered species and he's not sure that I should be out in the wild. After a little more small talk about our work and the people we still keep in touch with, Colin says, "You're like... older than me, now."

Now, what I really want to say is, "Actually genius, I'm four years younger than you, just like I've always been." I'm really not that mouthy, so I said something like, "Well, kids will do that to you." But it made me think a lot about what makes a grown-up. And to be honest, I don't think that I'm weird one here. I wanted to look at this cool, put together man and say, "Aren't you a grown up? You're 28 years old. If you aren't an adult, when are you planning on turning into one?" In actuality, we talked for about 45 minutes and it was a nice talk. We enjoyed catching up, said good luck and went our separate ways. But this isn't just about Colin, it's about a whole group of people who were born the same decade as me, yet they look at me as old.

Obviously, having a child makes people grow up. It gives you a responsibility that you might not feel otherwise. Responsibility can make a person more cautious or thoughtful, but it doesn't have to make you old. I may not stay out at the bars until 2am on a weeknight, but my family and social life are active. We simply choose activities that fit into our schedule. We spend weekends camping. We have friends over for a barbeque in the afternoon instead of drinks at 10pm. In general, we have a good time and enjoy ourselves. Parenting didn't make me boring, it just made me change my schedule.

I know that I feel like an adult. My real question about this whole situation, how can a 28 year old man not? You graduated college, got a job, presumably pay your bills. These are all responsibility-building accomplishments. What is it about getting married and having kids that designates adulthood? And Colin, what if you never get married and have kids? Are you really going to spend the rest of your life thinking of yourself as an adolescent? And do you realize how much that feeds into the twenty-something pre-adult stereotype? You are a successful man! You should not feel like a young kid when presented with a woman who has a child.

I'm not sure why it bugs me to be seen as the old one. I'm proud to be a responsible adult. But even if I didn't have a beautiful daughter, I would still want to feel like an adult. At some point in time, spending every night at a bar would become tedious. No matter how nice and worry-free apartment living is, owning a home is a wonderful feeling. These milestones can occur with or without a nine month hormone boost. And for you, Colin, I hope they do. I hope you get to feel like a grown up soon, because it's kind of fun.
But to all of the old acquaintences running around out there, I'm not old! I'm an adult. And if you don't understand the difference, you should start looking into it. Because being old may seem boring, but being a 28 year old non-adult seems kinds sad. And I'll go for boring over sad anyday

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

We Don't All Need to be Parents

So who remembers Maslow’s Hierarchy of needs? Anyone? Psych 101? Probably not, but Maslow hypothesized that human beings have levels of needs which they strive to fulfill. First were physiological needs like food and water. Then comes safety, bringing shelter and security. These were followed by the wishy-washy needs like social relationships, esteem and self-actualization. That last one, self-actualization, has come to mean many things to many people. Maslow described it as, “the desire for self-fulfillment”. I like to think of it as the Army slogan, “Be All You Can Be.” Maslow classified these needs so that he could show what motivates people. In my example, I have plenty to eat, a house and wonderful people in my life. Right now, I would be striving for esteem, trying to gain recognition and acknowledgement in my chosen career path that I’m doing a good job.


*Side note: Psych 101 is as far as I got. So if anyone has a better way to explain, share it with us. I’m really sorry if I botched it, this isn’t my expertise. But I promise, I do have a reason for attempting my explanation.

Recently, a group of psychologists has tried to change Maslow’s 70 year-old hierarchy. As reported by Lisa Belkin over at the New York Times, these academics have knocked self-actualization off the top of the hierarchy. The new order goes a little like this: physiological, safety, social, esteem, self-actualization, mate acquisition, mate retention and parenting.

Let’s all take a minute to think about this. Finding a partner and spawning some offspring is now a psychological need. For whom? Everyone? I know what you’re thinking. Surely, some idiotic doctor is not trying to persuade everyone that we have an innate desire to pair up two by two and settle down with a broad of kids. Tim Gunn isn’t even sleeping with anyone, let alone procreating, and he’s the epitome of all that we’re striving for. Does Karl have kids? I don’t think so. And they cannot be implying that Karl is still in need of anything.

In all seriousness, this redesign of Maslow’s needs has pissed some people off. And for good reason! One of the scientists defending this claim, Douglas Kenrick tries to explain that this new hierarchy isn’t supposed to be “aspirational”. They aren’t trying to tell us what we should be doing; they are just trying to explain why human beings act like they do. But honestly, I don’t care what semantics you use, calling it a “need” means that all of us inherently want it. And for all three of these added needs, that simply isn’t true. Not everyone wants to find a mate, lots of people don’t want to keep them around forever, and plenty of wonderfully satisfied people don’t want to be parents.

I am mother. I love being a mother and I would never wish for anything different. But if I wasn’t a mother, I don’t think that it would make me any less fulfilled as a human being. I think that’s a big problem with parenting today. Men and women are choosing to have children because they think it will complete something in their own life. Truly wonderful parents are happy with themselves first. Then they decide to share that joy with a child. Becoming a mother helped me grow in many ways, but it didn’t make me a better person. It made me a different person. There’s a distinction here that I think these academic psychologists are missing.

These people were trying to update a theory from 1943. In my opinion, they made it a lot more antiquated. Find a man, keep a man, pop out a baby. This is a pretty old fashioned list of goals. And I know plenty of people who choose to go this route and don’t find any type of self-actualization. We’re all striving to be the best we can be, but that doesn’t mean we’re all going in the same direction.

Sunday, September 12, 2010

Parenting Increases Your Risk for Depression

Yet another study is out to tell us that parents experience more depression than those without children. This time the New York Times is reporting that mothers and fathers are more at risk for depression during their child’s first year of life, and even into the next twelve years (though to a lesser degree). They also add that younger parents or parents who have financial trouble are at an even higher risk. To this last part I say, “Duh. Thanks for that.”


Though the study didn’t evaluate reasons for depression, they point to the usual suspects such as lack of sleep, new responsibilities and the everyday demands of parenting. I can’t help thinking that I’ve heard this all before. And once again, surprise surprise! Parenting changes your life quicker and more dramatically than almost anything else. Those adjustments can be difficult and stressful, which tends to lead to depression.

I do believe that parenting today seems to be more difficult than ever. The litany of parenting advice, telling us the million things we aren’t doing right, creates more guilt among parents than ever before. A friend of mine who tends to be pretty environmentally aware said, “I feel awful. I know disposable diapers are terrible for the environment. I just don’t have the time or energy to deal with laundering shit-catchers.” This woman is not just a mother, she has a full time job as an engineer. I completely agree, she doesn’t have time to deal with it. The thing I don’t agree on is feeling guilty about it! If I was a stay at home mom, I wouldn’t have the time or energy to deal with cloth diapers. My friend and I aren’t trying to ruin the environment; we’re trying to keep our sanity.

Fathers feel more pressure today, as well. Even if women are earning more than their partners, a man still wants to provide for his family. I know this because I asked my husband and I’m going to let him represent fathers in general. Not only should they be providing, they need to spend more time with their kids, help with the housework. In the majority of households, both parents work from the second they wake up until their kids’ heads hit the pillow. For my family, that’s 5:45am until about 8:30pm. Let me tell you, that’s a long day.

Even with all this depression, even if we aren’t as happy as our childless counterparts, people everywhere are still having kids. And if you ask us, after going through those long days and sleepless nights, would you rather have remained childless? No! We love our children and the majority of us love being parents. It’s not easy and it’s not always fun, it can demand more of us than we have to give, but we make it through. Because the rewards are worth it.

All of these studies seem to miss the important part. Today was the Colts’ opening game, (and I’m probably going to be mad about for the next month.) So this morning, we stopped over at my parents’ house and my mom was wearing a jersey. Three hours later, we sit down to watch the game and my daughter screams, “Go Mimi! You can do it, Mimi!” My husband and I were a little confused, until we realized that Brenna saw the jersey and thought her grandma was out playing football. And I guarantee you that every mother you can find has some kind of adorable and endearing story to tell you about their children today. Kids try, test and exhaust us. They also inspire, delight and motivate us.

So thank you, New York Times. We get it. Parenthood is hard. It can literally drive you crazy. But if I could change my situation, I wouldn’t. And I hope that someday soon, I get another little depression-inducing, happiness-sucking bundle of tears and disposable diapers.

Monday, August 30, 2010

I Don't Like Meg Whitman, But Not Because Her Sons Are Dicks

I don’t like Meg Whitman. I don’t agree with her policies and I would never vote for her in a million years. Even though I don’t like her, I think most of the stories about her children’s bad behavior are completely irrelevant and unfair. (I say ‘most’ because one son committed a crime and injured a woman. I can understand covering this.) Blogs and media outlets have been covering the antics of “the Harsh brothers” and digging up stories about drunken dorm parties and temper tantrums at rugby games. The biggest problem is that some people are using this as ammunition that Whitman couldn’t possibly be a good governor if she wasn’t a good mother.

First of all, we have no way of knowing whether or not Whitman was a good mother. Her children have never come out and spoken against her (that I’m aware of). Even the best parents in the world can produce less-than-stellar offspring. While parenting obviously contributes to a child’s personality and actions, it is not the only indicator. As children grow up, and especially once they move out on their own, their behavior is less and less a reflection of their parents’ teaching and more of an individual’s expression of their own thoughts and beliefs. You can argue that a parent instills those thoughts, but only to a point.

The best example of this: think back to your time in college. Think of those drunken nights with your friends, hookups you regret, classes you skipped and general disregard for society outside of the campus bubble. Did that reflect your parents? Sure, we can all pretend that we were angels in college and studied until midnight every night. But let’s be honest, I worked at a bar called Sanctuary and was required to wear a Catholic school girl uniform. My parents were intensely embarrassed by this, just like I would be if it were my daughter. And if my mother were running for political office, I bet someone would dig up of photo of me in that little plaid skirt. I would be portayed as the next Montana Fishburne before people realized that I’m now a happily married woman with an 8-5 job and a toddler. And most importantly, no one would realize that my mother was completely amazing. I just happened to be an idiot while I was in college. Like almost everyone I know.

Secondly, some blogs are asking if male politicians would be getting the same scrutiny? In fact, my first thought was, “Because she’s the mother, the children are her responsibility and so are their actions. What bullshit!” And then, I had to stop myself and think about the Bush twins. George Bush got terrible press every time his college-aged daughters made a mistake. People automatically assume that if your children mess up, it’s all your – the parents’ – fault. But not just as a mother, as a daughter, I’m not sure that’s the case. We’re all individuals and our actions should reflect our own personalities, not those are the people who raised us. Because personally, I wouldn’t want my parents blamed for all the dumb moves I’ve made. They were pretty incredible, even if I didn’t always live up to the example they set.

So if you aren’t going to vote for Meg Whitman, choose a reason like her views on immigration or global warming or gay marriage. Or maybe it’s because she says obnoxious things like “This is a battle for the soul of California.” That annoys me, too. But don’t vote against Meg Whitman because her sons happen to be douchey college kids. There are lots of those out there.