Search This Blog

Saturday, March 5, 2011

The Teacher I Want For My Daughter

Here in the Midwest, we're arguing a lot about education lately.  Wisconsin, obviously, and in Indiana and Ohio.  Teachers' unions are coming under attack.  Even before this, the dismal realization that we are no longer training our young people to be the best and brightest has made educational reform into a large issue.  First we heard about "No Child Left Behind" and then we moved into "Race To The Top".  This week, the New York Times asked why so many of us suddenly disliked teachers.

In response to that article, my first instinct was to write about one of the many amazing teachers who not only educated, but inspired me.  The thought of picking just one is intensely daunting.  There was Mrs. Fleck, who in second grade told me that being the only girl who won at ciphering was something to be proud of.  Mr. Yarnell, who taught me that reading wasn't just about learning, but could also be enjoyable.  High school teachers are always the easiest to thank, probably because we remember them the best.  Also, as we get older, we feel pretty sorry for people who deal with bratty teenagers their entire lives.  Mrs. Teegarden, who made me think about what I was reading in a hundred new ways, Mr. Pukrop, who would be appalled at the grammar I use on this site, Dr. East, who took more hours than you can imagine to help me get a 5 on the AP Calc test, Mr. Danley, who continues to be a positive influence in my life to this day... I'm still not naming everyone I'd like to.  And to think, I'm just one of hundreds of children who had the opportunity to be inspired by these amazing educators. 

All of us have stories of special teachers who changed our lives.  Even those who seem to despise the education system now can't help but have fond memories of a teacher who influenced them.  These stories are important and necessary.  But today, I'd like to share a different one.  I'd like to talk about the type of teacher that I want my daughter to have.

To all of the teachers out protesting, I hope my daughter has you or someone like you.  To all the educators taking to Facebook, Twitter, or newspaper editorial pages all over the country, please keep taking care of our children.  To all of you fighting to retain your rights and say in the way your schools are run, I thank you.  I thank you for fighting to do what you know is best.  Because, even though it's not said enough, you've all spent countless hours learning what is truly best for our children. 

Why on earth would I want those whining, disorderly masses of people to teach my child?  Because those men and women are proud of their work.  They know that the service they provide has value and that they should be respected for it.  They know how hard they work and they simply want to be fairly compensated for it.

It's astonishing to me that a political party, so obsessed with Ayn Rand at the moment, is trying to persecute people who know their value and demand that we acknowledge it.  The defenders of capitalism are trying to make monsters out of professionals who went to school, got their training and now want to be paid a fair wage.  Jonathon Cohn at The New Republic said that Republicans are trying to turn public employees (like teachers) into the new "welfare queens".  As many a progressive blogger has pointed out, there's a serious problem with this analogy.  THESE PEOPLE ARE WORKING*.  Both their pay and their retirement packages were agreed upon, not only by unions, but by the local governments that are now trying to discredit their own employees. 

I want my daughter to learn from people who are confident in their skills and who value their work.  I want her to be graded by those who believe in their trade and fight for those beliefs.  Whether they teach English or mathematics, whether they prescribe hours of homework or grade on a curve, these are the teachers that I hope to see in my daughter's schools.  That is, I hope that all these self-righteous and justifiably proud teachers are much more honorable than Rand's heros.  I ask them, as much as a moocher as it makes me, to stay and fight for our children.

*Forgive me for the all-caps.  I know.  I normally hate that, too.  And forgive for letting the term "welfare queen" slide, I am in no way saying that I agree with that terribly disgusting and naive description.

No comments:

Post a Comment