We're not in Wisconsin, but there's been a lot of protests here too. Indiana is another of the Midwest states that's protesting Right to Work legistlation, as well as educational reform that would diminish teacher's union bargaining power. I've been getting daily email updates about protests, rallies and support events. I've considered attending some, though I'm not quite sure yet.
One thing I do know; I won't be taking my daughter.
Months ago, I wrote about Tea Party coloring books and how much I disagree with them. I defiantly stated that "the best time to discuss those politics with your child is when they're old enough to form their own opinions, not indoctrinate them directly after potty-training". I have to admit, it was pretty easy to disagree with the Tea Party training loyal conservatives before they could even spell the word. I generally disagree with the Tea Party, this was just one more way.
Then a story popped up in the New York Times about a 3-year old at the Indiana State House, protesting with his father. The little man with the "Don't Tread On Me" placard was pretty popular with the union supporters. Honestly, I bet the child was completely adorable. But, even though it's harder to disagree this time than it was the last, I'm still not sure that political rallies are an appropriate place for children. Whether it's a philosophy I agree with or one I don't, union rights doesn't seem like the type of political issue that a child needs to have strong opinions about.
We all teach our children morals. As parents, it's our job to instill values and life lessons. I'm sure that there are plenty of people who would argue that teaching their children about their political beliefs was just another way of discussing morals and values. When it comes to the culture wars, I'm sure that plenty of parents feel that way. And honestly, there are some issues which I understand. Personally, I will teach my daughter that all people have the right to love whoever they want. I probably won't bring up marriage and the rights it grants (or doesn't grant), but I will teach her that all people should be treated equally and with respect. I guess, some people might see this as a political belief.
But the honest fact is that most political beliefs pit one side against another. They create two separate teams, one that's right and one that's wrong. Especially for children, who see almost everything as black and white, good vs. evil, with no middle ground at all, setting up political beliefs at an early age teaches you that the other party are the bad guys. When the truth of the matter, the one that we all know deep down, is that most people want what's best for their country. We just don't all agree on what "best" is. Even if we agree on the desired outcome, odds are we won't agree on how to get there.
This type of situation, one where both sides are filled with good people who are working their hardest to make their country a better place, yet they still disagree... that's a hard thing to communicate to young children. Actually, it's pretty much impossible.
Someday, I hope my daughter will feel motivated to get involved in her community. I hope she'll understand the importance of volunteering her time to causes she believes in, whether they're politcal, social or spiritual. But I don't want the foundation for that involvement to be a belief I indoctrinated before she could ride a bicycle. I want it to be something that she believes deep down, in a thoughtful and serious way. I want her to think about all those values and morals that I tried to teach her and apply them in the best way she sees fit. If it turns out that she has different political beliefs than I do, I hope we can discuss them intelligently and respectfully. I want these things for myself and my daughter. But I won't get there by introducing my daughter to politics before she's ready to understand its complexities.
Having children at political rallies makes for great theatre. It creates adorable and profound photo ops. It makes for good news. But it's not what I want for my daughter, whether I agree with the cause or not.

No comments:
Post a Comment