I know that mothers can be neurotic and paranoid. We're pretty sure that every little thing we do will have a lasting (and normally negative) impact on the rest of our child's life. And hey, that fear is a whole lot of pressure! Personally, I worry that a scantily clad waitress will negatively effect my daughter's body image. Do I have any proof? Not really. It's pretty difficult to proof a single thing's impact when there are a million different factors that go into child-rearing.
All that being said, I'm pretty positive that this psychologist is full of shit and trying to scare mothers into never buying their child another toy... ever. Because apparently, half the basic crap we grew up playing with will lead to huge psychological consquences for our young children. Here is Dr. Jared DeFife's "10 Holiday Gifts that will Cause Your Child Lasting Psychological Damage". As a helpful sidenote, I've added why this doctor needs to calm the fuck down.
1. Elf on the Shelf. The "Elf on the Shelf" is a Christmas tradition, where parents hide a small elf doll at various places around the house in the days leading up to Christmas. The elf on the shelf is a "scout elf". He watches over the children to make sure they are behaving and each night he flies to the North Pole to report back to Santa. The feeling of constantly being watched by a magical creature that is just waiting for you to screw up is surely a breeding ground for a lifetime of paranoid psychopathology.
The whole idea of Santa bringing presents is predicated on the "Naughty and Nice" lists. You have to behave if you want to get presents. That sounds like positive reinforcement to me.
2. The Game of Life. Ah yes, there's nothing better than a board game reminding you that you could easily be condemned to a lifetime of underpaid salaries, house fires, bankruptcy and childlessness.
Obviously, the Game of Life is sending out a terrible message here. You should probably play Clue instead, and figure out which one of your friends is a murderer. Or Battleship, because it's never too soon to start studying war strategy.
3. Fisher Price Medical Kit. Hypochondriacs rejoice! Now every cough, sniffle, or boo-boo can be treated as a major medical emergency.
God, who would ever want to encourage their children to find medicine interesting. It's not like you can make a career out of it. Let the little one know that it's ok as a "hobby", but not something to be taken seriously.
4. A Santa outfit. Dressing your child up in a Santa outfit for holiday photos is why your child will grow into an adolescent who hates you.
Ok, this might make your adolescent hate you. But all adolescents hate you. Trying to stop that is like trying to stop people from talking about Sarah Palin. Give it up already.
5. A Barbie doll or superhero action figure. Can you say body image issues?
Superheros can definitely create unrealistic expectations. Your child could start trying to fly or dangle on spider webs. Or think that they could have rock hard, plastic abs.
I'm not going to get into Barbie issues. They've been beaten to death. Yes, they can create body image issues too. Yet we have the whole Disney princess collection at home. Call me a hypocrite if you'd like.
6. The Magic 8-Ball. See Schizotypal Personality Disorder criteria #2: odd beliefs or magical thinking that influences behavior (e.g., belief in clairvoyance, telepathy, or "sixth sense"...)
I'm sure that asking a magic-8 ball if Jason Curtis would take me to the freshman semi-formal is the reason that I wasted my money on that stupid Call Cleo scam. I was just hooked from an early age. Do you think there's a lawsuit somewhere in there?
7. Curious George. He's an impulsive monkey with a pathological lack of attachment anxiety. Do you really want your child emulating this behavior? Hopefully your insurance plan covers stimulant medication.
Curious? You mean suicidal! Do you know what happens to monkeys who stray from their Mamas? They die! Please, lets all teach that lesson to our children. Then we can whine about them refusing to move out 40 years from now.
8. The Espressione Café Retro. Why is an espresso machine sold through the Toys R Us website? If your child is already hooked on caffeine, a substance abuse problem is definitely in the future.
Your child is just one Mountain Dew away from a heroin addiction. Think on that.
9. Tickle Me Elmo. Tickling a giggling furry creature is a sure-fire way to kick-start sexual fetishism.
You don't even want to know what the little freaks will do with Snuffaluffagus.
10. Etch-a-sketch. Your child will spend hours working on a deeply meaningful artistic creation, only to have it wiped away at the slightest jostling. A psychologically devastating reminder of the ubiquity of loss and the ephemeral nature of existence. Also, no building sand castles on the beach.
You had the next Degas on your hands. Then you shook his masterpiece away so you could try to write your name in connecting lines. Now he's going to waste his life in a low-level job and hate you until the day he dies.
