Search This Blog

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Rules, Are They Necessary?

My quick answer would be, "Yes."  Jada Pinkett Smith feels differently.  In a recent interview, the actress, wife and mother of three said, "We don’t have rules. We come up with agreements. Kids are little people, and we’re in life to guide them. Trying to rule someone is always an illusion, and it’s no different with children.”

While this seems like a nice, warm and cozy point of view, I can't help but find it a little unrealistic.  Maybe it's because my daughter is still a toddler.  Toddlers are very difficult to reason with and they normal find your logic boring.  The only way to ensure that my daughter is safe and healthy is to create rules and guidelines for her.  Do not climb up the staircase.  You may not go outside without an adult.  You cannot take your seat belt off while the vehicle is moving.  There's no reasoning these with my daughter.  These are rules, rules she has to follow or she will receive a punishment, most like a time out. 

Likewise, manners don't come naturally.  And at a young age, children don't have the empathy necessary to understand why manners are so important.  This is why I don't answer my daughter if she makes demands, instead of asking politely and ending with a "Please".  She knows that the rule in our house is to use your manners.  Smith explains, "I see my children as little people, not necessarily people to control."  Except I have no problem telling my daughter that I'm in charge at our house and she has to listen to me.  In a multitude of ways, I control my daughter.  And I see no problem with that.

Maybe Jada and I are talking about two very different experiences.  I have toddlers and she has teenagers, or pre-teens at least.  How old is Miss-Whip-My-Hair?  Maybe one day I won't see my relationship with my daughter as one of rules and boundaries.  But I'm not so sure. 

Even into their teen years, I believe that a parent has an obligation to be in control of their household.  No matter how many times that my daughter might try to argue about staying out late on a school night, it won't happen.  I don't care how persuasive she gets (and data so far suggest that I'm in for trouble here), poor grades will never be an option.  Until the day she moves out of my house, I'm pretty sure that I will always have rules for my daughter.  I'll communicate with her why I feel that these rules are necessary, but that doesn't mean that I'll debate them.  In the end, it will be mine and my husband's decision. 

So, am I just a hardass whose children will never create obnoxiously catchy music or star in 80s remakes?  Or are setting up and enforcing rules a necessary part or parenting?

No comments:

Post a Comment