Search This Blog

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Supporting Our Teachers

I believe that getting involved in the political process is part of being a good citizen.  So of course I've been in contact with my local representatives about their attempt to strip teachers of their collective bargaining rights.  Here's what's happening so far.

First, I sent a blanket letter through an advocate website.  Here's the original.

Representative,


Teachers and school employees, just like all workers, deserve the right to bargain for fair wages and working conditions. Silencing the voices of teachers in the classroom does nothing for Indiana's children and Indiana's public schools. I encourage you to vote 'No' on Senate Bill 575 and stop this needless attack on Indiana's teachers.

Sincerely,
Stilettos and Motherhood

Here's my rep's response.

Dear Stilettos and Motherhood,


Thank you for taking the time to voice your opposition to the education reform issues the Indiana House of Representatives is considering this year. The pieces of legislation dealing with education reform have been by far the most discussed bills of this session and I appreciate knowing your opinion.

The specific bill you mention is Senate Bill 575 which deals with teacher collective bargaining. I understand the concern that this bill will reduce the voice of teachers in the school system. However, if anything, I feel this bill would increase the kind of flexibility and local control that has been the focus of this year's discussion on education reform. Both supporters and detractors of these bills argue that control needs to be maintained at the local level. So much of what we are doing this year in the legislature addresses local control.

Currently, collective bargaining laws severely limit the ability of a superintendent to make crucial adjustments to curriculums, methodology, teacher-student ratios or to call staff meetings outside normal hours. In these tough economic times, when we are trying to maximize the effectiveness of our school funding, we need to pull ourselves away from the collective bargaining proposals that force schools into deficit financing and take away from the classroom. At the same time we need to be sure teachers have great opportunity to have their voices heard and to discuss any and all items that are of concern both in their classrooms and in their schools. This needs to happen not just at the bargaining table, but throughout the year. By limiting collective bargaining to wages and wage related benefits, SB 575 allows for input from teachers in policy decisions and takes away the distractions that hamper growth, innovation and adjustment to situations that were unforeseen during a long term contract negotiation. We want to be sure that teachers have the flexibility in their own classrooms to be spontaneous, implement new ideas and teaching strategies, and to feel comfortable approaching their principals and superintendents any day of the week. We want them to feel free to ask for help, to discuss their working conditions or teaching possibilities, or to find solutions to problems they struggle with without being tied to the provisions in a contract.

I have spent countless weeks listening to the discussions of the education reform bills and to the people they will affect. I have visited classrooms in my district, spoken to superintendents, teachers, and parents and have brought their concerns back to my colleagues in Indianapolis. I have addressed constituents at town hall meetings throughout the district and have discussed your concerns with the Department of Education and the authors of these bills. I can assure you that all of the bases I can possibly cover have been covered. The final votes I take on these bills have been (and will continue to be) informed decisions that I believe will help Hoosier children, and are not simply the will of our Governor, Superintendent of Public Instruction or the other members of the House Republican caucus.

Thank you so much for involving yourself in this process, but more than that, thank you for your love and dedication to the education of our children. As always, if you have any questions or further concerns, I encourage you to contact me. I look forward to hearing from you again.

And my follow up:

Representative Heuer,


I appreciate that you are putting such thought and consideration into this vote. Collective bargaining rights are not a matter to be taken lightly or decided through partisanship. I wish that I had been made aware of your town hall discussions and could have been able to participate.

As the daughter of a dedicated teacher in your district and the mother of a young child about to enter Fort Wayne Community Schools, I feel extremely passionate about teachers and education. I have volunteered many hours in local schools and supported them through donations of my money and time. I believe that both of us honestly want to do what is best for the education system.

However, I believe that if you're listening to the teachers, educators and assistants working in our schools, it is difficult to a support a bill that strips them of their rights to organize. People claim that unions make issues compicated and difficult, but they also make professionals feel safe, secure and appreciated. They work hard to listen to our teachers and fight for what will help both our educators and our students.  It seems counter-intuitive to say that limiting collective bargaining rights will somehow increase a teacher's ability to give input.  Also, how does stripping unions of their rights create a more safe environment?  These goals which you claim to be supporting are actually achieved through the unions.  Limiting them does the exact opposite of your stated objectives. 

Teachers are not some pampered class of citizens who receive more than their fair share. Teachers are overworked and underappreciated by the general public, and the Repulican party, as of late. These are people who dedicate their lives to the needs of our children. They deserve a voice in every matter that pertains to their compensation, their schools and their evaluations. They deserve respect, for themselves and for the unions who work tirelessly to make their voice heard.

I appreciate that you've taken the time to think long and hard about this decision. But I struggle to see how you could write that you've spoken with our state's teachers and then vote in a way that damages their morale, limits their rights and ultimately hurts our education system. I hope that you'll keep Indiana's teachers and their needs in mind as this topic continues to be debated in the legislature.

Sincerely,

Stilettos and Motherhood

No comments:

Post a Comment