Search This Blog

Monday, April 4, 2011

Why Decent People Aren't Furious About Victim-Blaming

As I read about the New York Times horrible coverage of the gut-wrenching repeated assault on an 11 year-old girl in Texas, I was angry.  I was disgusted and appalled and most of all, angry.  Even after they printed their please-don't-hate-us-piece follow-up, my anger didn't dissipate.  While the Times smartly opened the article with a more sympathetic view of the child victim, they still threw in a few quotes about how she kept sneaking out of the house.  True, they were just trying to use every quote the poor father would contribute, but I still didn't feel like it was necessary. 

While I spent weeks fuming about the first piece in the Times, deciding whether or not it was going to impact my newly necessary digital subscription, I was amazed at how not-angry everyone else was.  Let me explain, most people who would stumble across this site, they're angry.  Because either a) it's my father and I've raged about this for weeks so he understands (Hi, Dad!) or b) you're the type of person who reads decidedly feminist and liberal blogs on the internet.  The feminist blogosphere was every kind of angry about the media coverage surrounding this poor little girl.

But everyday people, the ones I work with or see at my daughter's gymnastics class, those people didn't see any problem with commenting on a pre-teen's clothing and make-up while reporting on her gang rape.  These people read such stories and fully agree with the woman who said, "Where was her mother?"  I couldn't understand how women with daughters could sympathize with a reporter who laid even the slightest amount of blame with a mother and her daughter, instead of with the multitude of men who raped an innocent child.

In contemplating the odd thought process behind this mindset, I came upon a very disturbing thought.  We allow victim-blaming, because we want to believe that if we don't allow our children to wear make-up or stay out late, they'll be safe.  We want the reassurance that there are choices we can make to keep our daughters and sons safe.  So then, if something terrible should happen, we accept the blame for another person's crime.  We accept guilt for failing to protect our children.  It's a huge psychological stress that we allow, because it's easier than admitting that terrible things can happen to everyone.

Whether we want to admit it or not, a female can be raped at the age of 11 or 50.  Rape occurs whether you're wearing fishnets or sweat pants.  Whether you carry mace in the grocery store or walk home alone at midnight, something terrible could happen.  I'm not saying that we shouldn't make smart choices and do everything we can to protect ourselves.  Of course we should.  But you can make every smart choice available to you and still become a victim.  Being a victim does not mean that you failed at keeping yourself safe.  It means that a criminal made a choice to do something awful. 

That thought... the one that we might be powerless to protect our children... it's a lot more terrifying than a little victim-blaming.  That helplessness induces a lot more rage than some ill-conceived quotes in a news story.  In the end, the majority of people are a lot more comfortable accepting the partial-blame for lax security than accepting the reality that we could all be victims.  And while we're all worrying about how to protect ourselves, we forget to be angry that we need to protect ourselves.  We spend so much effort making ourselves safe, we stop being furious that such crimes happen. 

I honestly believe that most people don't understand how this problem promotes a culture where rape is ok.  Let's face it, most people aren't in favor of rape.  They aren't praising or congratulating a rapist.  But they don't realize that everytime they mention something the victim should have done, they give the rapist one more excuse.  If the victim should have worn less revealing clothes, than the clothes made the rape occur.  If the victim should have been home before dark, than the darkness is to blame.  But human beings commit rape, not the circumstances surrounding them.  Human beings commit a terrible and violent act, and they are the only ones to blame.  Everytime we give them an excuse, everytime we talk about what the victim should have done, we ignore that a human being made a conscious decision to violate someone.  And no matter how safe we are, we can't always protect ourselves from someone else's decision. 

Lots of everyday people weren't outraged by the media coverage of a child's rape in Texas, but they should've been.  A little girl's life has been changed forever.  And no matter how careful we are, it could still happen to one of our children.

No comments:

Post a Comment