Here in the Midwest, we're arguing a lot about education lately. Wisconsin, obviously, and in Indiana and Ohio. Teachers' unions are coming under attack. Even before this, the dismal realization that we are no longer training our young people to be the best and brightest has made educational reform into a large issue. First we heard about "No Child Left Behind" and then we moved into "Race To The Top". This week, the New York Times asked why so many of us suddenly disliked teachers.
In response to that article, my first instinct was to write about one of the many amazing teachers who not only educated, but inspired me. The thought of picking just one is intensely daunting. There was Mrs. Fleck, who in second grade told me that being the only girl who won at ciphering was something to be proud of. Mr. Yarnell, who taught me that reading wasn't just about learning, but could also be enjoyable. High school teachers are always the easiest to thank, probably because we remember them the best. Also, as we get older, we feel pretty sorry for people who deal with bratty teenagers their entire lives. Mrs. Teegarden, who made me think about what I was reading in a hundred new ways, Mr. Pukrop, who would be appalled at the grammar I use on this site, Dr. East, who took more hours than you can imagine to help me get a 5 on the AP Calc test, Mr. Danley, who continues to be a positive influence in my life to this day... I'm still not naming everyone I'd like to. And to think, I'm just one of hundreds of children who had the opportunity to be inspired by these amazing educators.
All of us have stories of special teachers who changed our lives. Even those who seem to despise the education system now can't help but have fond memories of a teacher who influenced them. These stories are important and necessary. But today, I'd like to share a different one. I'd like to talk about the type of teacher that I want my daughter to have.
To all of the teachers out protesting, I hope my daughter has you or someone like you. To all the educators taking to Facebook, Twitter, or newspaper editorial pages all over the country, please keep taking care of our children. To all of you fighting to retain your rights and say in the way your schools are run, I thank you. I thank you for fighting to do what you know is best. Because, even though it's not said enough, you've all spent countless hours learning what is truly best for our children.
Why on earth would I want those whining, disorderly masses of people to teach my child? Because those men and women are proud of their work. They know that the service they provide has value and that they should be respected for it. They know how hard they work and they simply want to be fairly compensated for it.
It's astonishing to me that a political party, so obsessed with Ayn Rand at the moment, is trying to persecute people who know their value and demand that we acknowledge it. The defenders of capitalism are trying to make monsters out of professionals who went to school, got their training and now want to be paid a fair wage. Jonathon Cohn at The New Republic said that Republicans are trying to turn public employees (like teachers) into the new "welfare queens". As many a progressive blogger has pointed out, there's a serious problem with this analogy. THESE PEOPLE ARE WORKING*. Both their pay and their retirement packages were agreed upon, not only by unions, but by the local governments that are now trying to discredit their own employees.
I want my daughter to learn from people who are confident in their skills and who value their work. I want her to be graded by those who believe in their trade and fight for those beliefs. Whether they teach English or mathematics, whether they prescribe hours of homework or grade on a curve, these are the teachers that I hope to see in my daughter's schools. That is, I hope that all these self-righteous and justifiably proud teachers are much more honorable than Rand's heros. I ask them, as much as a moocher as it makes me, to stay and fight for our children.
*Forgive me for the all-caps. I know. I normally hate that, too. And forgive for letting the term "welfare queen" slide, I am in no way saying that I agree with that terribly disgusting and naive description.
Search This Blog
Saturday, March 5, 2011
Thursday, March 3, 2011
Children in Politics, Part II.
We're not in Wisconsin, but there's been a lot of protests here too. Indiana is another of the Midwest states that's protesting Right to Work legistlation, as well as educational reform that would diminish teacher's union bargaining power. I've been getting daily email updates about protests, rallies and support events. I've considered attending some, though I'm not quite sure yet.
One thing I do know; I won't be taking my daughter.
Months ago, I wrote about Tea Party coloring books and how much I disagree with them. I defiantly stated that "the best time to discuss those politics with your child is when they're old enough to form their own opinions, not indoctrinate them directly after potty-training". I have to admit, it was pretty easy to disagree with the Tea Party training loyal conservatives before they could even spell the word. I generally disagree with the Tea Party, this was just one more way.
Then a story popped up in the New York Times about a 3-year old at the Indiana State House, protesting with his father. The little man with the "Don't Tread On Me" placard was pretty popular with the union supporters. Honestly, I bet the child was completely adorable. But, even though it's harder to disagree this time than it was the last, I'm still not sure that political rallies are an appropriate place for children. Whether it's a philosophy I agree with or one I don't, union rights doesn't seem like the type of political issue that a child needs to have strong opinions about.
We all teach our children morals. As parents, it's our job to instill values and life lessons. I'm sure that there are plenty of people who would argue that teaching their children about their political beliefs was just another way of discussing morals and values. When it comes to the culture wars, I'm sure that plenty of parents feel that way. And honestly, there are some issues which I understand. Personally, I will teach my daughter that all people have the right to love whoever they want. I probably won't bring up marriage and the rights it grants (or doesn't grant), but I will teach her that all people should be treated equally and with respect. I guess, some people might see this as a political belief.
But the honest fact is that most political beliefs pit one side against another. They create two separate teams, one that's right and one that's wrong. Especially for children, who see almost everything as black and white, good vs. evil, with no middle ground at all, setting up political beliefs at an early age teaches you that the other party are the bad guys. When the truth of the matter, the one that we all know deep down, is that most people want what's best for their country. We just don't all agree on what "best" is. Even if we agree on the desired outcome, odds are we won't agree on how to get there.
This type of situation, one where both sides are filled with good people who are working their hardest to make their country a better place, yet they still disagree... that's a hard thing to communicate to young children. Actually, it's pretty much impossible.
Someday, I hope my daughter will feel motivated to get involved in her community. I hope she'll understand the importance of volunteering her time to causes she believes in, whether they're politcal, social or spiritual. But I don't want the foundation for that involvement to be a belief I indoctrinated before she could ride a bicycle. I want it to be something that she believes deep down, in a thoughtful and serious way. I want her to think about all those values and morals that I tried to teach her and apply them in the best way she sees fit. If it turns out that she has different political beliefs than I do, I hope we can discuss them intelligently and respectfully. I want these things for myself and my daughter. But I won't get there by introducing my daughter to politics before she's ready to understand its complexities.
Having children at political rallies makes for great theatre. It creates adorable and profound photo ops. It makes for good news. But it's not what I want for my daughter, whether I agree with the cause or not.
One thing I do know; I won't be taking my daughter.
Months ago, I wrote about Tea Party coloring books and how much I disagree with them. I defiantly stated that "the best time to discuss those politics with your child is when they're old enough to form their own opinions, not indoctrinate them directly after potty-training". I have to admit, it was pretty easy to disagree with the Tea Party training loyal conservatives before they could even spell the word. I generally disagree with the Tea Party, this was just one more way.
Then a story popped up in the New York Times about a 3-year old at the Indiana State House, protesting with his father. The little man with the "Don't Tread On Me" placard was pretty popular with the union supporters. Honestly, I bet the child was completely adorable. But, even though it's harder to disagree this time than it was the last, I'm still not sure that political rallies are an appropriate place for children. Whether it's a philosophy I agree with or one I don't, union rights doesn't seem like the type of political issue that a child needs to have strong opinions about.
We all teach our children morals. As parents, it's our job to instill values and life lessons. I'm sure that there are plenty of people who would argue that teaching their children about their political beliefs was just another way of discussing morals and values. When it comes to the culture wars, I'm sure that plenty of parents feel that way. And honestly, there are some issues which I understand. Personally, I will teach my daughter that all people have the right to love whoever they want. I probably won't bring up marriage and the rights it grants (or doesn't grant), but I will teach her that all people should be treated equally and with respect. I guess, some people might see this as a political belief.
But the honest fact is that most political beliefs pit one side against another. They create two separate teams, one that's right and one that's wrong. Especially for children, who see almost everything as black and white, good vs. evil, with no middle ground at all, setting up political beliefs at an early age teaches you that the other party are the bad guys. When the truth of the matter, the one that we all know deep down, is that most people want what's best for their country. We just don't all agree on what "best" is. Even if we agree on the desired outcome, odds are we won't agree on how to get there.
This type of situation, one where both sides are filled with good people who are working their hardest to make their country a better place, yet they still disagree... that's a hard thing to communicate to young children. Actually, it's pretty much impossible.
Someday, I hope my daughter will feel motivated to get involved in her community. I hope she'll understand the importance of volunteering her time to causes she believes in, whether they're politcal, social or spiritual. But I don't want the foundation for that involvement to be a belief I indoctrinated before she could ride a bicycle. I want it to be something that she believes deep down, in a thoughtful and serious way. I want her to think about all those values and morals that I tried to teach her and apply them in the best way she sees fit. If it turns out that she has different political beliefs than I do, I hope we can discuss them intelligently and respectfully. I want these things for myself and my daughter. But I won't get there by introducing my daughter to politics before she's ready to understand its complexities.
Having children at political rallies makes for great theatre. It creates adorable and profound photo ops. It makes for good news. But it's not what I want for my daughter, whether I agree with the cause or not.
Happy World Book Day!
I've loved reading since a very early age. I can still remember the very first chapter book that I sat down and read straight through. I was in 5th grade and it took me the whole day after Christmas. While my siblings played with toys or tried on new clothes, I sat cuddled in the couch and read all about Alanna, a girl pretending to be a boy so that she could be a knight. It was written by Tamora Pierce. I still own the entire 8-book series. Currently, they are sitting on my daughter's book shelf, just waiting for her to be old enough to want to hear them.
I have a lot of books from my childhood on those shelves. Some of them are picture books that we're beginning to enjoy right now. There's lots of Shel Silverstein and A.A. Milne. When I was pregnant, I read my daughter Peter Pan and Alice in Wonderland to calm her down and get her to stop crying. Once my daughter is old enough to hear entire chapters, we'll go back to the classics, those wonderfully vivid and imaginative books that make young children's eyes pop wide open and dreams become more colorful. Honestly, I can't wait! Currently, we go through about 3 picture books every night before Brenna's finally ready for bed. It's the best part of my day.
I've always loved reading. It's a joy that I learned very young from both my parents. They read early and often and all three of their children grew to love books. It was such an important part of our lives that if my dad left for business, sometimes for a month at a time, he would have to record himself reading to us. We'd press play and flip through the pages and pretend he was there with us. Now, they have books that record your voice for you at Hallmark. My daughter can carry her PaPa of Great-Grandma's voice around with her.
I can measure my life by the books I was reading at every age. From Jane Austen through high school, Gabriel Garcia Marquez in college and Rosalind Miles, by my bed at this very moment. Everything from Ayn Rand to Douglas Adams to Oscar Wilde, it's all inspired and entertained. Literature is an important part of our lives. And appreciating it is a skill that I hope to pass along to my own daughter.
So today, on World Book Day, I'd like to thank my parents for introducing me to one of the greatest passions in my life. I want to thank Tamora Pierce, wherever you are, for creating a story that a young girl could get lost in. It was the first of many and it was wonderful. And I want to hope that someday, I'll get to share this passion with my own daughter. I hope we'll stay up way too late just to finish another chapter. I hope we'll pick up a book when we need to relax and unwind. I hope she'll know all about the joy of reading.
And I hope every kid out there gets the same chance to appreciate literature that I'm trying to give my daughter. Today is a day to donate books to an inner-city school in your area. It's a day to give your child a new book. It's a day, more than anything, to find a wonderful story and read it to every child you can get your hands on. Happy World Book Day.
I have a lot of books from my childhood on those shelves. Some of them are picture books that we're beginning to enjoy right now. There's lots of Shel Silverstein and A.A. Milne. When I was pregnant, I read my daughter Peter Pan and Alice in Wonderland to calm her down and get her to stop crying. Once my daughter is old enough to hear entire chapters, we'll go back to the classics, those wonderfully vivid and imaginative books that make young children's eyes pop wide open and dreams become more colorful. Honestly, I can't wait! Currently, we go through about 3 picture books every night before Brenna's finally ready for bed. It's the best part of my day.
I've always loved reading. It's a joy that I learned very young from both my parents. They read early and often and all three of their children grew to love books. It was such an important part of our lives that if my dad left for business, sometimes for a month at a time, he would have to record himself reading to us. We'd press play and flip through the pages and pretend he was there with us. Now, they have books that record your voice for you at Hallmark. My daughter can carry her PaPa of Great-Grandma's voice around with her.
I can measure my life by the books I was reading at every age. From Jane Austen through high school, Gabriel Garcia Marquez in college and Rosalind Miles, by my bed at this very moment. Everything from Ayn Rand to Douglas Adams to Oscar Wilde, it's all inspired and entertained. Literature is an important part of our lives. And appreciating it is a skill that I hope to pass along to my own daughter.
So today, on World Book Day, I'd like to thank my parents for introducing me to one of the greatest passions in my life. I want to thank Tamora Pierce, wherever you are, for creating a story that a young girl could get lost in. It was the first of many and it was wonderful. And I want to hope that someday, I'll get to share this passion with my own daughter. I hope we'll stay up way too late just to finish another chapter. I hope we'll pick up a book when we need to relax and unwind. I hope she'll know all about the joy of reading.
And I hope every kid out there gets the same chance to appreciate literature that I'm trying to give my daughter. Today is a day to donate books to an inner-city school in your area. It's a day to give your child a new book. It's a day, more than anything, to find a wonderful story and read it to every child you can get your hands on. Happy World Book Day.
Wednesday, March 2, 2011
Salon Doesn't Hate Mothers
I was a little harsh on Salon this week. But they seemed pretty dismissive of motherhood in general, which made me critical. I have to admit, I'm glad to see that they presented another side of the story from one of their Open Salon blogs. Enjoy!
Foot Fetish: LAMB Platforms
I've always been a little confused by spring wardrobes. The weather is tumultuous and can never decide if it will stay around 50 or 30. There's a ton of moisture, be it rain, snow or sleet. It finally gets warm enough that you don't need a coat, but you still need to wear something reasonably warm. I just spent March and April feeling stuck between my winter and summer clothes. My choices become: wear something heavy that doesn't look like spring at all or shiver uncontrollably.
I think these Mary Jane platforms from LAMB do a good job of bridging the two seasons. They are close-toed, which I believe is necessary until it's actually warm outside. But the light and fun color definitely makes them feel like spring!
I think these Mary Jane platforms from LAMB do a good job of bridging the two seasons. They are close-toed, which I believe is necessary until it's actually warm outside. But the light and fun color definitely makes them feel like spring!
Mommy, What's In Your Tummy?
This weekend, we visited a friend who's pregnant. On our way there, we tried to explain to Brenna why our friend's tummy was so big. "Well Bean, she's carrying a baby in her tummy." Brenna furrowed her brow, pursed her lips, and after a couple minutes said, "That's weird."
Ok, so maybe we should leave it at that. Except now that we'd stated this conversation, Brenna wasn't done with it. "Mom, I do NOT want one," she told me emphatically. She kind of sounded like Veruca Salt after the trippy boat ride. "It's ok, you don't become a Mommy until you're much older." That was the best I could do. What can I say? I think Brenna was still pretty skeptical about the whole thing.
Then, after hearing from a friend that babies have to kick their way our of their mom's bellies, she was completely against the idea. Heaven help the girl if I ever do get pregnant. She's going to be terrified.
So I'm asking, honestly or humorously, what do you tell a toddler about pregnancy? What have you told your kinds, nephews or any other child you get the chance to corrupt?
Some responses from my family:
My Uncle: Just let them watch the movie Alien. They'll figure it out.
An Aunt: Tell the kid that you swallowed a basketball for lunch. (I actually did this once to a kindegartner and they totally bought it.)
General Concensus: It all started out as a watermelon seed.
Ok, your turn.
Ok, so maybe we should leave it at that. Except now that we'd stated this conversation, Brenna wasn't done with it. "Mom, I do NOT want one," she told me emphatically. She kind of sounded like Veruca Salt after the trippy boat ride. "It's ok, you don't become a Mommy until you're much older." That was the best I could do. What can I say? I think Brenna was still pretty skeptical about the whole thing.
Then, after hearing from a friend that babies have to kick their way our of their mom's bellies, she was completely against the idea. Heaven help the girl if I ever do get pregnant. She's going to be terrified.
So I'm asking, honestly or humorously, what do you tell a toddler about pregnancy? What have you told your kinds, nephews or any other child you get the chance to corrupt?
Some responses from my family:
My Uncle: Just let them watch the movie Alien. They'll figure it out.
An Aunt: Tell the kid that you swallowed a basketball for lunch. (I actually did this once to a kindegartner and they totally bought it.)
General Concensus: It all started out as a watermelon seed.
Ok, your turn.
Tuesday, March 1, 2011
Celebrity Children's Books
We've all seen Jamie Lee Curtis's children's books and I think we can all agree that they're wonderful. Honestly, the woman has written a lot of children's books. I haven't read them all, but those I have were nice and sweet. I would never buy a children's book simply because it was written by a celebrity, but I never thought that I would discount a book because of its author's notoriety.
Then, I read over at Crushable that Abe from The Real World had written a children's book. No seriously. This led me to wonder what other celebrities have reached out to the littlest among us. And are they people that we really want sharing stories with our kids?
I'm not saying that Abe, he of hot tub threesomes, might not have a wonderful story to share with kids. He might. But the honest truth is that celebrities are always whining about the public turning them into role models. How often have we heard that we shouldn't be so hard on celebrities misbehavior because they didn't ask for children to look up to them. Well.... if you wrote a children's book, you simply don't get to use that excuse. You're saying that you want inspire or educate or entertain young children. So if your public persona isn't one that I can share with my daughter, I probably won't be buying your merchandise.
Honestly, I wrote this introduction without even looking for more odd celebrity books. So let's hope I can find something.
Little T Learns to Share by Terrell Owens. Oh, T-O! You never disappoint, huh? Well, in fairness, this might have been a therapeutic and instructive exercise for Owens. I'm just not sure that his shrink meant for him to share it with the world.
But in the end, I think I'll stick to children's authors who do this type of thing for a living. I somehow get the idea that they take the whole thing much more seriously, and in the end write better books for my daughter. We're going to go read Dinosaurs Love Underpants now.
Then, I read over at Crushable that Abe from The Real World had written a children's book. No seriously. This led me to wonder what other celebrities have reached out to the littlest among us. And are they people that we really want sharing stories with our kids?
I'm not saying that Abe, he of hot tub threesomes, might not have a wonderful story to share with kids. He might. But the honest truth is that celebrities are always whining about the public turning them into role models. How often have we heard that we shouldn't be so hard on celebrities misbehavior because they didn't ask for children to look up to them. Well.... if you wrote a children's book, you simply don't get to use that excuse. You're saying that you want inspire or educate or entertain young children. So if your public persona isn't one that I can share with my daughter, I probably won't be buying your merchandise.
Honestly, I wrote this introduction without even looking for more odd celebrity books. So let's hope I can find something.
Little T Learns to Share by Terrell Owens. Oh, T-O! You never disappoint, huh? Well, in fairness, this might have been a therapeutic and instructive exercise for Owens. I'm just not sure that his shrink meant for him to share it with the world.Let George Do It by George Foreman. That's right, he of mini-grill success and professional boxing has a story all about the importance of... George. The book is about Foreman's family of Georges and has pictures of famous Georges throughout. Isn't it enough that college kids everywhere will be praising your name? Do you need to teach the little ones how important it is, too?
If Roast Beef Could Fly by Jay Leno. It's not like I would be a huge supporter of Conan's kids' book either. This isn't prejudice. I just don't know that a Late Show host needs to try to connect with the single-digit crowd. There's Jay's recognizable face, oddly morphed to a.... smoother appearance. But really, children shouldn't recognize you. Keep it past their bedtime.
Presenting... Tallulah by Tori Spelling. I hate to include this because it could be cute. But I have a hard time supporting a woman who earned back a marginal degree of noTORIety (see what I did there? Cute, huh? ...Not really? Are you sure?) by pimping out her family to anyone with a film crew.
Flanimals by Ricky Gervais. Long before he pissed off everyone at awards shows, Ricky Gervais wrote an entire series of children's book called Flanimals. Just in case you aren't sure who Gervais was actually marketing to, it says "from the creator of The Office" right there on the cover.
The Jolly Mon by Jimmy Buffett. Thank you Jimmy, but I'll teach my daughter about margaritas in a midnight mother/daughter ritual that includes dancing, singing, blenders and magic. Just like Stockard Channing would want me to.
When I Grow Up by Al Yankovic. Didn't he do a duet with Coolio? I think that counts him out.
Mud Tacos by Mario Lopez. Listen Slater, you were never exactly a good influence on my childhood. I'm not sure if I'm cool with you influencing my daughter's. Especially after that whole "creating a Barbie doll" news with your girlfriend.
I have to admit, there were lots of children's books by celebrities. I stayed away from Madonna, because that was discussed to death when it came out. Although I do think the Sex book was more her thing. The fact is, lots of celebrities can get published simply because they have name recognition.
Daily Rant: Screw You, Random Salon Contributor
It's been a while since I ranted. They really aren't daily. Unless of course, you're my husband. He gets to listen to these daily. Poor man.
So, Salon has a tendency to publish random life stories from writers who are promoting books. They are normally well-written and a tad controversial. I assume they are just bait for the message boards and I normally ignore them. But this one pisses me off. A lot.
Today's random bit of wisdom comes from Rahna Reiko Rizzuto and it's entitled "Why I left my children". The minute I opened it, I know that I was going to hate it, but I read anyways. Normally, I try to be supportive of different people's mothering tactics. I've always wished that mothers would be a little more encouraging and a little less critical of each other. Yet, I don't feel bad criticizing this woman, because she describes herself as a "part-time mother" and she's ok with that. Oh, she has all the excuses that you would expect to hear. She never wanted to be a mother. She's more involved now than she ever used to be. A woman can be more than a mother. The double standard that men can walk away and women can't. Her weekly visits are filled with family meals and games and lovey dovey sweetness. Her children even hug her in public. Blah Blah Blah.
Yes, lady, all of that is bullshit. It's self-serving excuses and lots of bullshit. I bet your part-time motherhood does seem a lot more fun than actual parenting. You don't have any of the responsibility. You don't put your children to bed and then wake up in the middle of the night if one of them doesn't feel well. You don't have to discipline in any substantial way. You have plenty of free time to accomplish all the things you need to for yourself and then, you get to play with the kids. You get all the fun of children without any of the responsibility. You're what my husband would call "Aunt Mommy".
I do have some prejudice here. My daughter happens to have an "Uncle Daddy." Her father has no custody to speak of, but he sees her once every couple weeks. I have to be honest, this situation works out well for me. I don't have to do any compromising about how I raise my daughter. My daughter's father and I don't have a lot of arguments, because there's not much to say. He made a choice to never have our daughter overnight, to not have a legal say in her upbringing. I believe that my daughter and I have been better off because of this. We've been able to move on. And my daughter has an amazing stepfather who is there to share in all of the parenting work. He's there for sick days and lazy weekends. He's there whether his work schedule gets hectic or his social life gets exciting, and our daughter knows that.
I don't think that attendance at basketball games and parent teacher conferences means that you're just like every other parent. Those activities, they're easy. Of course they are important, but it's not too difficult to show up to a scheduled event. It's the rehearsals that part-time parents miss. It's the homework after the game. It's the nights where the whole family is home, going about their normal lives. Part-time parents always have an out. They have their alone time, just a few hours away.
Every once in a while, I think that it must be nice to only have to deal with the fun or important times. It must be nice to know that tomorrow, or the next day, you can sleep in as long as you want to. I don't have a day to sleep in for the forseeable future and envy people who choose their own time to wake up. (My husband works odd hours and isn't home until 11am on the weekends.) Yes, part-time parenting sounds like fun. But it doesn't sound like actual parenting.
You might miss a lot of the temper tantrums, but you're also not there to teach them the lesson after the crying has stopped. You miss the moodiness, but you don't hear the problem behind it. And then you don't have to fix anything. Part-time parenting is all about happiness and fun. But even though they're small, children know that there is more to life than that. And they know if you're avoiding those parts. Or just missing them.
Listen, I'm happy that people like Rahna didn't completely run off on their children. I'm happy that they still try to have a relationship with their kids. I'm happy that my daughter will get to know her father. But trying to defend this type of situation as if you weren't walking out on your children is bullshit. Trying to pretend that you're still a mother, just with a different style, is false advertising. You aren't a mother, not in the everyday-no-matter-what kind of way. And your husband, he does deserve praise, though maybe not sainthood. Not because he's a man who chose to take care of your children, but because he's the parent who takes care of all the difficult stuff while you're gone. Oh, and whether you wanted children or not, you had them. Claiming ambivalence after the fact is never an excuse, it's just insulting to your kids.
So screw you, random salon contributor. You might not see a big difference between your part-time motherhood and real parenting, but I guarantee your children do.
So, Salon has a tendency to publish random life stories from writers who are promoting books. They are normally well-written and a tad controversial. I assume they are just bait for the message boards and I normally ignore them. But this one pisses me off. A lot.
Today's random bit of wisdom comes from Rahna Reiko Rizzuto and it's entitled "Why I left my children". The minute I opened it, I know that I was going to hate it, but I read anyways. Normally, I try to be supportive of different people's mothering tactics. I've always wished that mothers would be a little more encouraging and a little less critical of each other. Yet, I don't feel bad criticizing this woman, because she describes herself as a "part-time mother" and she's ok with that. Oh, she has all the excuses that you would expect to hear. She never wanted to be a mother. She's more involved now than she ever used to be. A woman can be more than a mother. The double standard that men can walk away and women can't. Her weekly visits are filled with family meals and games and lovey dovey sweetness. Her children even hug her in public. Blah Blah Blah.
Yes, lady, all of that is bullshit. It's self-serving excuses and lots of bullshit. I bet your part-time motherhood does seem a lot more fun than actual parenting. You don't have any of the responsibility. You don't put your children to bed and then wake up in the middle of the night if one of them doesn't feel well. You don't have to discipline in any substantial way. You have plenty of free time to accomplish all the things you need to for yourself and then, you get to play with the kids. You get all the fun of children without any of the responsibility. You're what my husband would call "Aunt Mommy".
I do have some prejudice here. My daughter happens to have an "Uncle Daddy." Her father has no custody to speak of, but he sees her once every couple weeks. I have to be honest, this situation works out well for me. I don't have to do any compromising about how I raise my daughter. My daughter's father and I don't have a lot of arguments, because there's not much to say. He made a choice to never have our daughter overnight, to not have a legal say in her upbringing. I believe that my daughter and I have been better off because of this. We've been able to move on. And my daughter has an amazing stepfather who is there to share in all of the parenting work. He's there for sick days and lazy weekends. He's there whether his work schedule gets hectic or his social life gets exciting, and our daughter knows that.
I don't think that attendance at basketball games and parent teacher conferences means that you're just like every other parent. Those activities, they're easy. Of course they are important, but it's not too difficult to show up to a scheduled event. It's the rehearsals that part-time parents miss. It's the homework after the game. It's the nights where the whole family is home, going about their normal lives. Part-time parents always have an out. They have their alone time, just a few hours away.
Every once in a while, I think that it must be nice to only have to deal with the fun or important times. It must be nice to know that tomorrow, or the next day, you can sleep in as long as you want to. I don't have a day to sleep in for the forseeable future and envy people who choose their own time to wake up. (My husband works odd hours and isn't home until 11am on the weekends.) Yes, part-time parenting sounds like fun. But it doesn't sound like actual parenting.
You might miss a lot of the temper tantrums, but you're also not there to teach them the lesson after the crying has stopped. You miss the moodiness, but you don't hear the problem behind it. And then you don't have to fix anything. Part-time parenting is all about happiness and fun. But even though they're small, children know that there is more to life than that. And they know if you're avoiding those parts. Or just missing them.
Listen, I'm happy that people like Rahna didn't completely run off on their children. I'm happy that they still try to have a relationship with their kids. I'm happy that my daughter will get to know her father. But trying to defend this type of situation as if you weren't walking out on your children is bullshit. Trying to pretend that you're still a mother, just with a different style, is false advertising. You aren't a mother, not in the everyday-no-matter-what kind of way. And your husband, he does deserve praise, though maybe not sainthood. Not because he's a man who chose to take care of your children, but because he's the parent who takes care of all the difficult stuff while you're gone. Oh, and whether you wanted children or not, you had them. Claiming ambivalence after the fact is never an excuse, it's just insulting to your kids.
So screw you, random salon contributor. You might not see a big difference between your part-time motherhood and real parenting, but I guarantee your children do.
Monday, February 28, 2011
New Gloss Post: How Hot is Too Hot?
Today, at The Gloss, I'm asking: Can Moms Still Be Sexy? Answer the survey and weigh in on the comments.
Maybe An Overreaction...
Over at Salon, Mary Elizabeth Williams is taking Natalie Portman to task for calling her pregnancy "the most important role of my life". Williams, whose work I thoroughly enjoy on a reglar basis, doesn't understand why Portman has to downplay the biggest achievement of her career (winning an Oscar) by comparing it to carrying a baby.
I've never won an Oscar, so I'm pretty sure that I can't relate to trying to accept the award without looking and sounding like a complete idiot. I imagine that this is more difficult than one would think. And maybe I just love Natalie Portman in all her awkward adorableness, but I think she deserves some slack here.
Yes, lots of wonderful women have done amazing things in their career, even if they have children. Yes, lots of women without children have done amazing things. And no, a woman's sole purpose on this earth isn't to raise cute mini-me's or spawn the future generation. Most women in the 21st century get that. We're thankful that we have opportuities to be both great mothers and successful professionals.
But there is something about pregnancy that makes a woman feel special and incredibly proud of her ability to produce children. Be as pessimistic about pregnancy as you like, talk about the nausea, the swollen ankles and the crippling heartburn, we all discuss those things frequently. No matter how rotten your body may feel, the realization that it's growing another person is amazing. Feeling the heartbeat and the kicks and the movement, it's an incredible experience. It's not the only incredible experience in a woman's life. But it's a key one.
So if Natalie Portman is so high on pregnancy that she wants to refer to it as her most important performance, let her. Smile and nod and wish her the very best. For some women, they decide that being a mother really is the most important thing they will ever do. They have every right to feel that way. And you know what, I commmend them for making that commitment. Some women choose to be mothers and also have a career. I'm happy for them too. Just because Natalie Portman has already made amazing professional accomplishments doesn't mean that she can't decide to be a mother and nothing else. Whatever she decides, we should all be happy for her.
And if it turns out that this was just one of those light-headed pregnancy moments brought on by the joy of WINNING AN OSCAR, let's support her when she goes back to work, too. Basically, there are a lot of feminist issues to tackle out there. I don't think a euphoric acceptance speech is one of them.
Congratulations Ms. Portman! I wish you and your little one the very best.
I've never won an Oscar, so I'm pretty sure that I can't relate to trying to accept the award without looking and sounding like a complete idiot. I imagine that this is more difficult than one would think. And maybe I just love Natalie Portman in all her awkward adorableness, but I think she deserves some slack here.
Yes, lots of wonderful women have done amazing things in their career, even if they have children. Yes, lots of women without children have done amazing things. And no, a woman's sole purpose on this earth isn't to raise cute mini-me's or spawn the future generation. Most women in the 21st century get that. We're thankful that we have opportuities to be both great mothers and successful professionals.
But there is something about pregnancy that makes a woman feel special and incredibly proud of her ability to produce children. Be as pessimistic about pregnancy as you like, talk about the nausea, the swollen ankles and the crippling heartburn, we all discuss those things frequently. No matter how rotten your body may feel, the realization that it's growing another person is amazing. Feeling the heartbeat and the kicks and the movement, it's an incredible experience. It's not the only incredible experience in a woman's life. But it's a key one.
So if Natalie Portman is so high on pregnancy that she wants to refer to it as her most important performance, let her. Smile and nod and wish her the very best. For some women, they decide that being a mother really is the most important thing they will ever do. They have every right to feel that way. And you know what, I commmend them for making that commitment. Some women choose to be mothers and also have a career. I'm happy for them too. Just because Natalie Portman has already made amazing professional accomplishments doesn't mean that she can't decide to be a mother and nothing else. Whatever she decides, we should all be happy for her.
And if it turns out that this was just one of those light-headed pregnancy moments brought on by the joy of WINNING AN OSCAR, let's support her when she goes back to work, too. Basically, there are a lot of feminist issues to tackle out there. I don't think a euphoric acceptance speech is one of them.
Congratulations Ms. Portman! I wish you and your little one the very best.
Labels:
Celebrities,
motherhood,
Natalie Portman,
Pregnancy,
Salon
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









